Department of Forensic Medicine, Lumbini Medical College, Palpa, Nepal.
Lumbini Medical College, Palpa, Nepal.
J Nepal Health Res Counc. 2024 Jun 22;22(1):150-156. doi: 10.33314/jnhrc.v22i01.4941.
Death certificates provide vital data for disease surveillance and health policy. However, errors are common globally, undermining data reliability. This study analyzed prevalence and types of errors in death certificates at a tertiary hospital in Nepal.
A cross-sectional study reviewed all death certificates issued at Lumbini Medical College, Nepal from April 2020 to April 2022. Certificates were assessed for errors including improper sequencing, absent time intervals, abbreviations, illegible writing, and inaccurate immediate, antecedent, and underlying causes of death as per international guidelines. Errors were classified as major or minor.
Of 139 certificates, none were error-free. The most common error was incorrectly or incompletely filling the immediate cause of death (77.7%). Other errors included absent time of death (17.3%), abbreviations (57.6%), illegible writing (22.3%), and omitting the hospital stamp/medical council registration number (8.6%). Based on international criteria, 76.3% had minor errors, 23% had both major and minor errors.
This study found a high rate of errors in death certification at a tertiary hospital in Nepal, undermining data accuracy. Regular training and monitoring with feedback are recommended to improve certification practices. Accurate cause-of-death data is vital for healthcare policy and decision-making in Nepal.
死亡证明为疾病监测和卫生政策提供了重要数据。然而,错误在全球范围内普遍存在,破坏了数据的可靠性。本研究分析了尼泊尔一家三级医院死亡证明中的错误发生率和类型。
本横断面研究回顾了 2020 年 4 月至 2022 年 4 月在尼泊尔蓝毗尼医学院签发的所有死亡证明。根据国际指南,评估证书是否存在错误,包括顺序不当、时间间隔缺失、缩写、书写不清以及直接、先前和根本死因不准确。错误分为主要错误和次要错误。
在 139 份证书中,没有一份是无错误的。最常见的错误是直接死因填写不正确或不完整(77.7%)。其他错误包括死亡时间缺失(17.3%)、缩写(57.6%)、书写不清(22.3%)以及遗漏医院印章/医学委员会注册号码(8.6%)。根据国际标准,76.3%的证书有轻微错误,23%的证书有主要错误和次要错误。
本研究发现尼泊尔一家三级医院的死亡证明中存在很高的错误率,影响了数据的准确性。建议进行定期培训和监测,并提供反馈,以改进证明实践。准确的死因数据对尼泊尔的医疗保健政策和决策至关重要。