Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2024 Sep 15;210(6):715-729. doi: 10.1164/rccm.202407-1320ST.
Individuals with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are often at risk for or have comorbid cardiovascular disease and are likely to die of cardiovascular-related causes. To prioritize a list of research topics related to the diagnosis and management of patients with COPD and comorbid cardiovascular diseases (heart failure, atherosclerotic vascular disease, and atrial fibrillation) by summarizing existing evidence and using consensus-based methods. A literature search was performed. References were reviewed by committee co-chairs. An international, multidisciplinary committee, including a patient advocate, met virtually to review evidence and identify research topics. A modified Delphi approach was used to prioritize topics in real time on the basis of their potential for advancing the field. Gaps spanned the translational science spectrum from basic science to implementation: ) disease mechanisms; ) epidemiology; ) subphenotyping; ) diagnosis and management; ) clinical trials; ) care delivery; ) medication access, adherence, and side effects; ) risk factor mitigation; ) cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation; and ) health equity. Seventeen experts participated, and quorum was achieved for all votes (>80%). Of 17 topics, ≥70% agreement was achieved for 12 topics after two rounds of voting. The range of summative Likert scores was -15 to 25. The highest priority was "Conduct pragmatic clinical trials with patient-centered outcomes that collect both pulmonary and cardiac data elements." Health equity was identified as an important topic that should be embedded within all research. We propose a prioritized research agenda with the purpose of stimulating high-impact research that will hopefully improve outcomes among people with COPD and cardiovascular disease.
慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)患者常存在或合并心血管疾病,并可能因心血管相关原因而死亡。为了优先列出与 COPD 合并心血管疾病(心力衰竭、动脉粥样硬化血管疾病和心房颤动)患者的诊断和管理相关的研究课题清单,我们对现有证据进行了总结,并采用基于共识的方法。进行了文献检索。由委员会联合主席审查参考文献。一个包括患者代言人在内的国际多学科委员会通过虚拟会议来审查证据并确定研究课题。采用改良 Delphi 方法实时优先考虑可能推进该领域发展的课题。差距贯穿转化科学的整个范围,从基础科学到实施:)疾病机制;)流行病学;)亚表型;)诊断和管理;)临床试验;)护理提供;)药物获取、依从性和副作用;)风险因素缓解;)心脏和肺康复;和)健康公平。有 17 名专家参与,所有投票的法定人数(>80%)都达到了。在两轮投票后,有 12 个课题获得了≥70%的专家共识。总结性 Likert 评分的范围为-15 至 25。优先级最高的是“开展以患者为中心的结局为重点的实用临床试验,同时收集肺部和心脏数据元素。”健康公平被确定为一个重要的课题,应该嵌入到所有研究中。我们提出了一个优先研究议程,旨在激发高影响力的研究,希望能改善 COPD 和心血管疾病患者的结局。