Abdo Sarah N, Hsu Jeremy L, Kapetanakis Constantine, Newman Dina L, Wright L Kate, Bailey Jennifer
Portland State University, College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, 1825 SW Broadway, Portland, Oregon 97207, United States.
Chapman University, Schmid College of Science and Technology, 1 University Dr., Orange, California 92866, United States.
J Chem Educ. 2024 Aug 27;101(9):3624-3634. doi: 10.1021/acs.jchemed.3c01355. eCollection 2024 Sep 10.
Effective spatial visualization and reasoning skills are often credited for students' success in science and engineering courses. However, students enrolled in these science courses are not always exposed to or trained properly on the best ways to utilize models to aid in their learning. Improving spatial visualization techniques with 3D models, such as molecular and DNA modeling kits, is often suggested to facilitate students' ability to conceptualize compounds in two and three dimensions. Here, we investigate what techniques students use to conceptualize 2D representations of various biomolecules with the use of 3D models by interviewing undergraduate students from various natural science and engineering disciplines in task-based, think-aloud sessions. After scoring and analyzing the participant data we explored some of the techniques used among successful scoring participants, including the use of informal models to transition between 2D and 3D. Additional techniques used by students who were able to successfully conceptualize 3D images included starting with smaller, granular details to inductively make conclusions when thinking between two and three dimensions. We find that (1) students who anchor their thinking in 3D models show a deeper level of understanding in initially solving science problems successfully, and (2) proper 3D model use and spatial visualization techniques may improve students' abilities to accurately visualize 2D and 3D representations of molecules in science courses. Our results demonstrate that implementing spatial visualization training to teach students how to effectively use 3D models may improve students' problem-solving techniques in science curricula.
有效的空间可视化和推理能力常常被认为是学生在科学和工程课程中取得成功的原因。然而,参加这些科学课程的学生并不总是接触到或接受关于如何最好地利用模型来辅助学习的适当培训。人们经常建议使用3D模型,如分子和DNA建模工具包,来提高空间可视化技术,以促进学生在二维和三维空间中对化合物进行概念化的能力。在这里,我们通过在基于任务的出声思考环节中采访来自不同自然科学和工程学科的本科生,研究学生使用哪些技术通过3D模型对各种生物分子的二维表示进行概念化。在对参与者的数据进行评分和分析之后,我们探索了成功得分的参与者所使用的一些技术,包括使用非正式模型在二维和三维之间转换。能够成功对3D图像进行概念化的学生使用的其他技术包括从较小的、具体的细节入手,在二维和三维思考之间归纳得出结论。我们发现:(1)将思维锚定在3D模型上的学生在最初成功解决科学问题时表现出更深层次的理解;(2)正确使用3D模型和空间可视化技术可能会提高学生在科学课程中准确可视化分子二维和三维表示的能力。我们的结果表明,实施空间可视化培训以教导学生如何有效使用3D模型可能会提高学生在科学课程中的问题解决技巧。