Kaiser Permanente Division of Research, Pleasanton, California.
The Kaiser Permanente CREST Network, Pleasanton, California.
JAMA Health Forum. 2024 Nov 1;5(11):e244156. doi: 10.1001/jamahealthforum.2024.4156.
Telemedicine is an increasingly used yet understudied vehicle to deliver pediatric primary care. Evidence detailing downstream health care utilization after telemedicine visits is needed.
To compare pediatric primary care conducted via telemedicine (video or telephone) with in-person office visits with regard to physician medication prescribing and imaging and laboratory ordering and downstream follow-up office visits, emergency department (ED) visits, and hospitalizations.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cohort study included all patients younger than 18 years who had scheduled primary care appointments with a pediatrician from January 1 to December 31, 2022, in the Kaiser Permanente Northern California health system, a large integrated health care delivery system offering in-person office visits, video visits, or telephone visits for pediatric primary care.
Pediatric primary care in-person visit, telephone visit, or video visit.
Rates of physician medication prescribing and imaging and laboratory ordering during an index telemedicine or office visit and rates of in-person office visits, ED visits, and hospitalizations within 7 days after the visit, adjusted for patient and clinical characteristics.
Of 782 596 total appointments (51.1% male) among 438 638 patients, telemedicine was used for 332 153 visits (42.4%). After adjustment, there was more medication prescribing for in-person visits (39.8%) compared with video visits (29.5%; adjusted difference, -10.3%; 95% CI, -10.6% to -10.0%) or telephone visits (27.3%; adjusted difference, -12.5%; 95% CI, -12.5% to -12.7%). There was also more laboratory ordering for in-person visits (24.6%) compared with video visits (7.8%; adjusted difference, -16.8%; 95% CI, -17.0% to -16.6%) or telephone visits (8.5%; adjusted difference, -16.2%; 95% CI, -16.3% to -16.0%). There was more imaging ordering for in-person visits (8.5%) compared with video visits (4.0%; adjusted difference, -4.5%; 95% CI, -4.6% to -4.4%) and telephone visits (3.5%; adjusted difference, -5.0%; 95% CI, -5.1% to -4.9%). After adjustment, fewer in-person follow up visits occurred for index visits that were in-person (4.3%) compared with video (14.4%; adjusted difference, 10.1%; 95% CI, 9.9%-10.3%) or telephone (15.1%; adjusted difference, 10.8%; 95% CI, 10.7%-11.0%) visits. The rate of ED visits following an in-person visit was slightly lower (1.75%) compared with after video visits (2.04%; adjusted difference, 0.29%; 95% CI, 0.21%-0.38%) or telephone visits (2.00%; adjusted difference, 0.25%; 95% CI, 0.18%-0.33%). There was no statistically significant difference in the 7-day rate of hospitalizations.
In this cohort study, telephone and video visits for pediatric primary care were associated with less prescribing and ordering than in-person visits. Telemedicine visits were associated with modestly higher rates of subsequent in-person visits and slightly higher rates of ED visits, and there was no difference in hospitalizations. Telemedicine appears to be a useful vehicle for health care delivery in the pediatric population, although it is not a universal substitute for in-person visits.
远程医疗是提供儿科初级保健的一种越来越被使用但研究不足的手段。需要详细了解远程医疗就诊后的医疗保健利用情况。
比较通过远程医疗(视频或电话)进行的儿科初级保健与面对面门诊就诊在医生开药、影像学和实验室检查、后续门诊就诊、急诊就诊和住院治疗方面的情况。
设计、地点和参与者:本队列研究纳入了 2022 年 1 月 1 日至 12 月 31 日期间,在 Kaiser Permanente 北加州卫生系统接受儿科医生预约的所有年龄小于 18 岁的患者,这是一个大型综合医疗服务系统,提供面对面门诊就诊、视频就诊或电话就诊服务。
面对面门诊就诊、电话就诊或视频就诊。
在索引远程医疗或门诊就诊期间医生开药物和影像学及实验室检查的比率,以及就诊后 7 天内的面对面门诊就诊、急诊就诊和住院治疗的比率,调整了患者和临床特征。
在 438638 名患者的 782596 次预约中(51.1%为男性),使用远程医疗的有 332153 次(42.4%)。调整后,面对面就诊的开药率(39.8%)高于视频就诊(29.5%;调整后的差异,-10.3%;95%CI,-10.6%至-10.0%)或电话就诊(27.3%;调整后的差异,-12.5%;95%CI,-12.5%至-12.7%)。面对面就诊的实验室检查开单率(24.6%)也高于视频就诊(7.8%;调整后的差异,-16.8%;95%CI,-17.0%至-16.6%)或电话就诊(8.5%;调整后的差异,-16.2%;95%CI,-16.3%至-16.0%)。面对面就诊的影像学检查开单率(8.5%)也高于视频就诊(4.0%;调整后的差异,-4.5%;95%CI,-4.6%至-4.4%)和电话就诊(3.5%;调整后的差异,-5.0%;95%CI,-5.1%至-4.9%)。调整后,面对面就诊的索引就诊后续门诊就诊的就诊率(4.3%)低于视频就诊(14.4%;调整后的差异,10.1%;95%CI,9.9%-10.3%)或电话就诊(15.1%;调整后的差异,10.8%;95%CI,10.7%-11.0%)。面对面就诊后急诊就诊的发生率略低(1.75%),低于视频就诊(2.04%;调整后的差异,0.29%;95%CI,0.21%-0.38%)或电话就诊(2.00%;调整后的差异,0.25%;95%CI,0.18%-0.33%)。7 天内的住院率无统计学差异。
在这项队列研究中,与面对面就诊相比,儿科初级保健的电话和视频就诊与开药和检查的比率较低。远程医疗就诊与后续门诊就诊的就诊率略高、急诊就诊率略高,但住院率无差异。远程医疗似乎是儿科人群医疗保健的一种有用手段,尽管它不是面对面就诊的普遍替代手段。