Suppr超能文献

加纳试点混合式学习即时超声课程后医生的临床经验与观点——一项混合方法分析

Physicians' clinical experience and perspectives following a pilot, blended learning, point of care ultrasound course in Ghana- a mixed methods analysis.

作者信息

Pathak Anna, Limbani Felix, Awuku Yaw Asante, Booth Angela, Joekes Elizabeth

机构信息

University of Oxford Medical School, Oxford, UK.

NHS Tayside, Dundee, UK.

出版信息

BMC Med Educ. 2024 Dec 4;24(1):1415. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-06250-z.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Point of Care ultrasound (POCUS) is rapidly gaining popularity in resource constrained settings. Optimising training is important to ensure safe and effective implementation. To expand POCUS expertise in Ghana, we co-developed and piloted a context specific, multi-disciplinary, blended learning programme, targeted at physicians of any grade or speciality providing acute care in the public health sector. In this retrospective mixed method study, we capture the "real world" experience of participants, using POCUS in their daily practice, as well as the barriers and enablers they perceived to implementation.

RESULTS

Eight emergency and internal medicine specialists and residents participated, working across three teaching hospitals, treating both general and specialist patients. They implemented each POCUS application taught, with cardiac indications, inferior vena cava (IVC) assessment, deep venous thrombosis (DVT) diagnosis, lung/pleural assessment and peripheral vascular access being most frequent at 3-6 times/week. An estimated 40% of patients could not have afforded any other diagnostic tests. They considered the pilot curriculum adequate for general practice and the majority of applications of low difficulty (71%). For cases sent for second opinion, they are self-reported that their findings were confirmed in 60-78% of cases. Perceptions about the relative advantage of POCUS over the usual approaches to diagnosing patients enabled implementation. Generally, they believed that POCUS improved their clinical decision making and that more certified training courses need to be run at lower cost to make them more accessible. All participants valued ongoing connections after training to ask for help and consolidate their skills. Continued evaluation and reflection on their POCUS practice to improve quality was unanimously reported as important, yet none had a formal system for this. The strongest barrier was access to equipment and maintenance. A lack of training opportunities and local mentors, and negative beliefs from other departments and hospital administration were further barriers.

CONCLUSION

Our new blended learning curriculum met the needs of physicians caring for patients with general and specialist presentations, with strong reported positive experience of improved bedside diagnostic capabilities, especially for the large proportion of patients unable to afford or access alternative diagnostic tests. Their experience drives the need for further training and for solutions to current barriers of equipment availability, training costs and lack of quality assurance mechanisms.

摘要

背景

床旁超声检查(POCUS)在资源有限的环境中迅速普及。优化培训对于确保安全有效地实施至关重要。为了在加纳扩展POCUS专业知识,我们共同开发并试点了一个针对特定环境、多学科、混合式学习项目,目标受众是在公共卫生部门提供急性护理的任何级别或专业的医生。在这项回顾性混合方法研究中,我们记录了参与者在日常实践中使用POCUS的“真实世界”体验,以及他们认为的实施障碍和促进因素。

结果

八名急诊和内科专科医生及住院医师参与其中,他们在三家教学医院工作,治疗普通患者和专科患者。他们实施了所教授的每项POCUS应用,心脏指征、下腔静脉(IVC)评估、深静脉血栓形成(DVT)诊断、肺部/胸膜评估和外周血管通路最为常见,每周进行3至6次。估计有40%的患者负担不起任何其他诊断检查。他们认为试点课程足以满足一般实践需求,并且大多数应用难度较低(71%)。对于送去寻求二次诊断意见的病例,他们自我报告称其检查结果在60%至78%的病例中得到了证实。对POCUS相对于常规患者诊断方法的相对优势的认知促进了其实施。总体而言,他们认为POCUS改善了他们的临床决策,并且需要以更低的成本开设更多认证培训课程,以使这些课程更容易获得。所有参与者都重视培训后的持续联系,以便寻求帮助并巩固他们的技能。一致报告称,持续评估和反思他们的POCUS实践以提高质量很重要,但没有人有正式的评估体系。最主要的障碍是设备获取和维护。缺乏培训机会和当地指导人员,以及其他科室和医院管理层的负面看法也是进一步的障碍。

结论

我们新的混合式学习课程满足了照顾普通患者和专科患者的医生的需求,报告显示他们在提高床边诊断能力方面有强烈的积极体验,特别是对于很大一部分负担不起或无法获得替代诊断检查的患者。他们的经验表明需要进一步培训,并需要解决当前设备可用性、培训成本和缺乏质量保证机制等障碍。

相似文献

本文引用的文献

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验