Dissaux Brieg, Robert Alexis, Duigou Marie, Lefèvre Christian, Ognard Julien, Seizeur Romuald
Univ Brest, Inserm, UMR 1304, GETBO, Brest, France.
Anatomy Department, University of Western Brittany (UBO), Brest, France.
Surg Radiol Anat. 2024 Dec 11;47(1):27. doi: 10.1007/s00276-024-03520-9.
Numerous studies have already reported on the anatomy of the superficial temporal artery (STA) on dissection or imaging, and more specifically on CT angiography. However, few studies have reported on the possible variations that exist between readers in the assessment of certain anatomical parameters. The aim of this study was to investigate the reproducibility of different anatomical measurements of the superficial temporal artery with CT angiography.
Forty cranial iodine contrast-enhanced CT scans were searched in a retrospective monocentric study. Various anatomical categorical and quantitative measurements (more or less automatic) of the superficial temporal artery were assessed. To evaluate the inter-observer reproducibility of various anatomical measurements of the superficial temporal artery obtained through CT angiography, descriptive statistics, kappa statistics and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) were employed.
Eighty STAs were analyzed independently by two readers. The kappa coefficient for determining the mode of STA termination was substantial (kappa = 0.782). The number of loops was mean 0.22 vs. 0.25 (p = 0.981; ICC = 0.701) and the number of kinks was mean 5.68vs5.64 (p = 0.876; ICC = 0.860). No significant difference was found between readers for the determination of the distance of the STA termination to different superficial landmark lines. No significant difference in the orientation angles of the STA and the frontal and parietal branches was found. Semi-automatic measurements of the length of the STA appeared (ICC > 0.7) reproducible whereas semi-automatic measurements (surface, perimeter, short diameter, large diameter) appeared statistically less reproducible (ICC < 0.5). These results must also be interpreted in the light of the spatial resolutions inherent in the CT angiography technique.
The present study provides information concerning the reproducibility of certain anatomical measurements of the superficial temporal artery in CT angiography.
众多研究已经报道了颞浅动脉(STA)在解剖或影像学检查中的解剖结构,尤其是在CT血管造影方面。然而,很少有研究报道在评估某些解剖参数时读者之间可能存在的差异。本研究的目的是探讨CT血管造影对颞浅动脉不同解剖测量的可重复性。
在一项回顾性单中心研究中,检索了40例头颅碘对比增强CT扫描。评估了颞浅动脉的各种解剖分类和定量测量(或多或少自动进行)。为了评估通过CT血管造影获得的颞浅动脉各种解剖测量的观察者间可重复性,采用了描述性统计、kappa统计和组内相关系数(ICC)。
两名读者独立分析了80条STA。确定STA终止方式的kappa系数较高(kappa = 0.782)。环的数量平均为0.22对0.25(p = 0.981;ICC = 0.701),扭结的数量平均为5.68对5.64(p = 0.876;ICC = 0.860)。在确定STA终止点到不同浅表标志线的距离时,读者之间未发现显著差异。在STA以及额支和顶支的方向角度上未发现显著差异。STA长度的半自动测量似乎具有可重复性(ICC > 0.7),而半自动测量(面积、周长、短径、长径)在统计学上的可重复性较低(ICC < 0.5)。这些结果还必须结合CT血管造影技术固有的空间分辨率来解释。
本研究提供了关于CT血管造影中颞浅动脉某些解剖测量可重复性的信息。