Shammout Ali, Berry Shamsi D, Ziemkowski Peter, Kroth Philip J
Department of Biomedical Informatics, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker, M.D., School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, Michigan, United States.
Appl Clin Inform. 2025 Mar;16(2):369-376. doi: 10.1055/a-2502-7158. Epub 2024 Dec 16.
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic accelerated the adoption of telehealth. Long-term implications for continued telehealth use on a large scale in primary care are still emerging, and the key to this understanding is how telehealth adoption impacts the delivery of health care.
Our objective was to quantify how telehealth adoption during the pandemic impacted patients' access to health care and the usage patterns of different access modalities (in-office, audio, and video).
This study analyzed 2 years of deidentified electronic health record data from the ambulatory clinics at a Midwest medical school from 2020 and 2021. We focused on patient demographics, primary diagnoses, and patient preferences for receiving health care throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.
Of the 105,362 patient visits analyzed across in-office, audio, and video visits, demographic data varied by gender, age, and racial composition. During the early pandemic, telehealth usage peaked in April 2020, with audio and video visits accounting for 45.8 and 18.1% of the total visits, respectively. These rates declined to averages of 12.5 and 3.6%, respectively, over the following months. Primary diagnoses during telehealth visits are often related to COVID-19 exposure or mental health or behavioral issues. Lastly, statistically significant associations exist between the visit modality and primary diagnoses.
The COVID-19 pandemic initially saw a surge in audio telehealth visits; however, as safety measures were established, the mix of visit modalities returned to prelockdown levels. Video and audio telehealth maintained increased usage relative to prepandemic levels, potentially owing to increased awareness of the technology as a means for accessing health care and a learning curve associated with adoption. Patients preferred remote care during high COVID-19 transmission. Video telehealth has shown significant associations with psychiatric, behavioral, and neurodevelopmental diagnoses. Disparities in video telehealth use among racial groups have highlighted potential access issues.
2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行加速了远程医疗的采用。在初级保健中大规模持续使用远程医疗的长期影响仍在显现,而理解这一点的关键在于远程医疗的采用如何影响医疗保健的提供。
我们的目标是量化大流行期间远程医疗的采用如何影响患者获得医疗保健的机会以及不同就诊方式(门诊、音频和视频)的使用模式。
本研究分析了一所中西部医学院门诊诊所2020年和2021年两年的去识别化电子健康记录数据。我们关注患者人口统计学、主要诊断以及在整个COVID-19大流行期间患者接受医疗保健的偏好。
在分析的105362次门诊、音频和视频就诊中,人口统计学数据因性别、年龄和种族构成而有所不同。在大流行初期,远程医疗的使用在2020年4月达到峰值,音频和视频就诊分别占总就诊次数的45.8%和18.1%。在接下来的几个月里,这些比例分别降至平均12.5%和3.6%。远程医疗就诊期间的主要诊断通常与COVID-19暴露或心理健康或行为问题有关。最后,就诊方式与主要诊断之间存在统计学上的显著关联。
COVID-19大流行初期音频远程医疗就诊激增;然而,随着安全措施的建立,就诊方式的组合恢复到封锁前的水平。视频和音频远程医疗的使用相对于大流行前水平有所增加,这可能是由于对该技术作为获得医疗保健手段的认识提高以及与采用相关的学习曲线。在COVID-19高传播期间,患者更喜欢远程护理。视频远程医疗与精神、行为和神经发育诊断显示出显著关联。不同种族群体在视频远程医疗使用方面的差异突出了潜在的获取问题。