Tran Thi Phuong Thao, Nguyen Thi Ngoc Phuong, Vu Thu Trang, Tran Thai Uyen, Nguyen Don, Phan Thi Hai, The Son Dao, Lim Min Kyung, Quah Anne C K, Oh Jin-Kyoung, Van Minh Hoang
Center for Population Health Sciences, Hanoi University of Public Health, Hanoi University of Public Health, Hanoi, Vietnam.
Department of Health Policy and Behavioral Sciences, School of Public Health, Georgia State University, Atlanta, United States.
Tob Induc Dis. 2024 Dec 17;22. doi: 10.18332/tid/196675. eCollection 2024.
No longitudinal study has investigated the impact of cigarette tax increases on retail prices in Vietnam. This study aims to describe changes in the purchase price of cigarettes following an excise tax increase from 70% to 75% in January 2019.
Data were collected from people who currently smoke cigarettes in the longitudinal ITC Vietnam surveys: 1870 participants in Wave 1 (pre-increase), 1564 in Wave 2 (post-increase), and 1308 in Wave 3 (post-increase). Weighted mean self-reported prices of a cigarette pack (with standard error) were calculated for participants who were successfully followed up across three waves. These mean prices were calculated for domestic and international brands, categorized by specific cigarette brands. Percentage changes in mean prices were also measured, and significant differences in mean prices between follow-up waves (Waves 2 and 3) and the baseline (Wave 1) were assessed using paired t-tests. For brands with very small sample sizes, we used non-parametric tests, specifically the Wilcoxon signed-rank test instead of paired t-tests.
The weighted mean price of a cigarette pack remained low and stable: VND 12330 (US$0.54) in 2018, VND 12700 (US$0.55) in 2019, and VND 12120 (US$0.53) in 2020 (1000 Vietnamese Dongs about US$0.04345, at 2018). International brands were substantially more expensive than domestic brands, but prices for both remained constant across all waves. Among domestic brands, Thang Long and Sai Gon showed slight price increases of around 3% and 5%, respectively (p<0.05). Among international brands, no statistically significant increase in mean prices was observed.
The retail price of cigarettes remains low, indicating that the slight tax increase was insufficient to raise the current retail price significantly. Therefore, a substantial increase in cigarette prices by adding a specific tax is necessary.
尚无纵向研究调查越南提高卷烟税对零售价格的影响。本研究旨在描述2019年1月消费税从70%提高到75%后卷烟购买价格的变化。
数据收集自越南国际烟草控制(ITC)纵向调查中目前吸烟的人群:第1波(提税前)有1870名参与者,第2波(提税后)有1564名,第3波(提税后)有1308名。对成功随访三期的参与者计算了每包香烟的加权平均自我报告价格(及标准误差)。这些平均价格按国内和国际品牌计算,并按特定卷烟品牌分类。还测量了平均价格的百分比变化,并使用配对t检验评估随访期(第2波和第3波)与基线期(第1波)之间平均价格的显著差异。对于样本量非常小的品牌,我们使用非参数检验,具体为威尔科克森符号秩检验而非配对t检验。
每包香烟的加权平均价格一直较低且稳定:2018年为12330越南盾(0.54美元),2019年为12700越南盾(0.55美元),2020年为12120越南盾(0.53美元)(2018年,1000越南盾约合0.04345美元)。国际品牌比国内品牌贵得多,但两者价格在各期均保持不变。在国内品牌中,升龙和西贡分别有小幅价格上涨,约为3%和5%(p<0.05)。在国际品牌中,未观察到平均价格有统计学显著增加。
卷烟零售价格仍然较低,表明小幅增税不足以显著提高当前零售价格。因此,有必要通过增加从量税大幅提高卷烟价格。