Leung Michael, Rowland Sebastian T, Modest Anna M, Hacker Michele R, Papatheodorou Stefania, Wei Yaguang, Schwartz Joel, Coull Brent A, Wilson Ander, Kioumourtzoglou Marianthi-Anna, Weisskopf Marc G
Department of Epidemiology, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts.
Department of Environmental Health, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts.
Am J Epidemiol. 2024 Dec 26. doi: 10.1093/aje/kwae475.
Identifying the determinants of pregnancy loss is a critical public health concern. However, pregnancy loss is often not noticed, and even when it is, it is inconsistently recorded. Thus, past studies have been limited to medically-identified losses or small, highly selected cohorts, which can lead to biased or non-generalizable results. We show mathematically and through simulations a novel approach that overcomes this measurement challenge to infer effects about pregnancy loss by utilizing more available data: the number of conceptions that led to live births-i.e., live-birth-identified conceptions (LBICs). We simulated ten years of conceptions, pregnancies, losses, and births under several confounding patterns, and two NO2-pregnancy loss relationships (no effect, mid-gestation effect). We fitted distributed lag models (DLMs) adjusted for season, year, and temperature, and assessed model performance through bias and coverage. Our simulations showed that our models, across all scenarios, identified the two NO2-pregnancy loss relationships with appropriate coverage (>90% of confidence intervals captured the true effect) and low bias (never exceeded ±2%). In an applied example using NO2-a traffic emissions tracer-and live birth data from a large tertiary-care hospital in Massachusetts, USA, we found that higher prenatal NO2 was associated with more pregnancy losses. Our proposed approach based on LBICs provides an alternative way to study causes of pregnancy loss.
确定流产的决定因素是一个关键的公共卫生问题。然而,流产情况往往未被注意到,即便被注意到,记录也不一致。因此,过去的研究仅限于医学认定的流产情况或小型的、经过高度筛选的队列,这可能导致结果有偏差或缺乏普遍性。我们通过数学方法和模拟展示了一种新方法,该方法利用更多可用数据——即导致活产的受孕数量(即活产认定的受孕,LBICs)来克服这一测量挑战,从而推断流产的影响。我们在几种混杂模式以及两种二氧化氮与流产的关系(无影响、孕中期影响)下模拟了十年的受孕、妊娠、流产和出生情况。我们拟合了针对季节、年份和温度进行调整的分布滞后模型(DLM),并通过偏差和覆盖率评估模型性能。我们的模拟表明,在所有情况下,我们的模型都能以适当的覆盖率(>90%的置信区间包含真实效应)和低偏差(从未超过±2%)识别出两种二氧化氮与流产的关系。在美国马萨诸塞州一家大型三级护理医院的应用实例中,我们使用二氧化氮(一种交通排放示踪剂)和活产数据,发现孕期较高的二氧化氮水平与更多的流产相关。我们基于LBICs提出的方法为研究流产原因提供了一种替代途径。