Waterman Emily A, Edwards Katie M, Hopfauf Skyler, Herrington Ramona, Mullet Natira, Trujillo Preciouse
Bennington College, 1 College Drive, Bennington, VT 05201, United States of America.
University of Michigan, School of Social Work, United States of America.
Child Abuse Negl. 2025 Mar;161:107230. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2024.107230. Epub 2025 Jan 13.
Given high rates of adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) among Indigenous youth, it is critical to develop and evaluate strategies to prevent these experiences; one part of evaluation is process evaluation, including analysis of fidelity, attendance and barriers to attendance, contamination, and program acceptability.
To present a process evaluation of Tiwahe Wicagwicayapi, a strengths-based, family-based program for predominantly Indigenous youth (ages 10 to 14) and their caregivers. The program aimed to prevent ACEs including child abuse and neglect.
The project included 124 families from a small-sized city in the Great Plains region of the United States.
The mixed-method evaluation included multiple data sources, including researcher-collected and observations, and participant surveys and interviews.
Results indicated 93 % fidelity on average. About three-quarters of caregivers and children attended at least one session, and the primary barriers to attendance included busyness, medical events, and transportation issues. Contamination was common (32.6 % among children and 36.2 % among caregivers), reflecting the close-knit nature of the surrounding community and consistent with extended kinship systems in Indigenous communities. Finally, participants found the program acceptable and impactful, particularly programming directly related to Lakota culture, traditions, and ceremony.
Findings indicate the importance of cultural relevance to successful and effective programming. These process data along with outcome data published elsewhere suggest that the Tiwahe Wicagwicayapi program is a promising approach to prevent ACEs including child abuse and neglect among Indigenous children.
鉴于美国原住民青年中童年不良经历(ACEs)的发生率很高,制定和评估预防这些经历的策略至关重要;评估的一部分是过程评估,包括对保真度、出勤率和出勤障碍、污染以及项目可接受性的分析。
对Tiwahe Wicagwicayapi进行过程评估,这是一个以优势为基础、以家庭为基础的项目,主要针对原住民青年(10至14岁)及其照顾者。该项目旨在预防包括虐待和忽视儿童在内的ACEs。
该项目包括来自美国大平原地区一个小城市的124个家庭。
混合方法评估包括多个数据源,包括研究人员收集的数据和观察结果,以及参与者调查和访谈。
结果表明平均保真度为93%。大约四分之三的照顾者和儿童至少参加了一次课程,出勤的主要障碍包括忙碌、医疗事件和交通问题。污染很常见(儿童中为32.6%,照顾者中为36.2%),这反映了周边社区关系紧密的性质,并且与原住民社区的扩展亲属制度一致。最后,参与者认为该项目是可接受且有影响力的,特别是与拉科塔文化、传统和仪式直接相关的项目。
研究结果表明文化相关性对于成功且有效的项目规划很重要。这些过程数据以及其他地方发表的结果数据表明,Tiwahe Wicagwicayapi项目是预防包括虐待和忽视原住民儿童在内的ACEs的一种有前景的方法。