Kruger Ryno, Lourenco Stella F
Department of Psychology, Emory University, Atlanta, USA.
Sci Rep. 2025 Jan 24;15(1):3065. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-86626-3.
Stereotypes are not only pervasive, they can also lead to discrimination against negatively-stereotyped groups. A gender-intelligence stereotype holds that men and boys are smarter than women and girls, despite no such evidence. Developmental research suggests that even children endorse this stereotype, and negative perceptions about self-worth in girls may be a consequence. Here we tested whether the stereotype about intelligence may, instead, be rooted in facial dominance, such that faces higher in dominance are considered smarter than faces lower in dominance. Across two studies, we found that 6- to 10-year-olds used facial dominance to make intelligence judgments (Experiment 1), even under divided attention (Experiment 2). Children judged more dominant faces as smarter than less dominant faces, whether the two faces were male or female. They did not, however, judge men as smarter than women when selecting between male and female faces that were matched in dominance. What is more, there was some evidence that children considered dominant female faces to be smarter than less dominant male faces, suggesting that dominance in faces may be prioritized over face gender when intuiting intelligence. These findings contrasted with children's judgments of niceness where both dominance, and a gender stereotype, were used to infer prosociality. Altogether, our findings provide novel evidence for an association between dominance and intelligence, which appears to predate a gender-intelligence stereotype.
刻板印象不仅普遍存在,还会导致对被负面刻板化群体的歧视。一种性别与智力的刻板印象认为,男性和男孩比女性和女孩更聪明,尽管并无此类证据。发展心理学研究表明,甚至儿童也认同这种刻板印象,而女孩对自我价值的负面认知可能就是其后果。在此,我们测试了关于智力的刻板印象是否反而源于面部的主导性,即主导性较高的面孔会被认为比主导性较低的面孔更聪明。在两项研究中,我们发现6至10岁的儿童会利用面部主导性来做出智力判断(实验1),即使在注意力分散的情况下也是如此(实验2)。无论两张面孔是男性还是女性,儿童都会判断主导性更强的面孔比主导性较弱的面孔更聪明。然而,当在主导性相当的男性和女性面孔之间进行选择时,他们并不会判断男性比女性更聪明。此外,有证据表明儿童认为主导性强的女性面孔比主导性弱的男性面孔更聪明,这表明在直观判断智力时,面孔的主导性可能比面孔的性别更重要。这些发现与儿童对友善程度的判断形成对比,在判断友善程度时,主导性和性别刻板印象都会被用来推断亲社会行为。总的来说,我们的研究结果为面部主导性与智力之间的关联提供了新证据,这种关联似乎早于性别与智力的刻板印象。