This review contributes to the knowledge on the complex and adaptive microbial ecosystems within cheese, emphasizing their critical role in determining cheese quality, flavor, and safety. This review synthesizes the current knowledge on the microbial interactions and the dynamics of lactic acid bacteria (LAB), encompassing both starter (SLAB) and non-starter (NSLAB) strains, which are pivotal to the curd fermentation and ripening processes. The adaptability of these microbial consortia to environmental and technological stressors is explored, highlighting their contributions to acidification, proteolysis, and the development of distinctive organoleptic characteristics. Historical and technological perspectives on cheesemaking are also discussed, detailing the impact of milk treatment, starter culture selection, and post-renneting procedures on microbial activity and biochemical transformations. This review underscores the importance of microbial diversity and cooperative interactions in fostering ecosystem resilience and metabolic functionality, and it addresses the challenges in mimicking the technological performance of natural starters using selected cultures. By understanding the ecological roles and interactions of cheese microbiota, this review aims to guide improvements in cheese production practices. Additionally, these insights could spark the development of innovative strategies for microbial community management.