Castelli Dransart Dolores Angela, Pedrazzini Scozzari Elena
School of Social Work, HES-SO University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland, Fribourg, Switzerland.
Front Psychiatry. 2025 Mar 11;16:1537038. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2025.1537038. eCollection 2025.
Assisted suicide is still a controversial issue among health and social care providers. They are likely to face challenges in end-of-life care in long-term facilities for older adults, both on organizational and professional levels. Although Swiss professionals are not involved in the final act, they are involved to various extents in the process which leads to the death.
This qualitative study was carried out in 12 facilities in French-speaking Switzerland, which had been faced with requests for suicide assistance from older adults. A total of 36 professionals (physicians, nurses, nursing assistants, social workers, directors) were interviewed. Data were analyzed according to Grounded Theory principles.
The results uniquely describe how the process unfolds within facilities, from the initial request for suicide assistance to the aftermath of death. This process gives rise to many questions concerning the most appropriate ethical, professional and organizational way to respond to the requests and provide specific support to the requesting person, their family, and staff within the institution. Institutional life and daily operations are significantly impacted. Major adjustments are required to procedures, usual care routines, resource allocation and communication management within the facility. Institutions that set out a clear framework for the way in which the request is handled and provide sufficient and appropriate support for staff are the least disrupted, not only in terms of their operations, but also in terms of cohesion within teams and relationships between care teams and management.Throughout the process, communication within the institution is fundamental to enable staff members to find their bearings and make sense of the situation.
Several cross-cutting issues are identified: the need to strike a balance between respecting the procedures laid down by law or the directives of professional associations, and the need to open up spaces for exchange and the construction of meaning for those involved in the process. Further issues include the preparation and training of professionals, and the support provided to them throughout the process. Training and support seem critical to maintaining the continuity and quality of care, motivation and the health of staff.
协助自杀在医疗和社会护理提供者中仍是一个有争议的问题。在老年人长期护理机构的临终关怀中,他们可能在组织和专业层面上面临挑战。尽管瑞士专业人员不参与最终行为,但他们在导致死亡的过程中在不同程度上有所参与。
这项定性研究在瑞士法语区的12个机构中进行,这些机构曾面临老年人的自杀协助请求。总共采访了36名专业人员(医生、护士、护理助理、社会工作者、主任)。数据根据扎根理论原则进行分析。
结果独特地描述了该过程在机构内如何展开,从最初的自杀协助请求到死亡后果。这个过程引发了许多问题,涉及应对请求并为请求者、其家人以及机构内工作人员提供具体支持的最适当的伦理、专业和组织方式。机构生活和日常运营受到重大影响。设施内的程序、日常护理常规、资源分配和沟通管理都需要进行重大调整。为处理请求的方式制定明确框架并为工作人员提供充分适当支持的机构受到的干扰最小,不仅在运营方面,而且在团队凝聚力以及护理团队与管理层之间的关系方面。在整个过程中,机构内的沟通对于使工作人员能够找准方向并理解情况至关重要。
确定了几个贯穿各领域的问题:需要在遵守法律规定的程序或专业协会的指令之间取得平衡,以及需要为参与该过程的人开辟交流空间并构建意义。其他问题包括专业人员的准备和培训,以及在整个过程中为他们提供的支持。培训和支持对于维持护理的连续性和质量、工作人员的积极性和健康似乎至关重要。