Fukuda Eren, Scott Katharine E, Swerbenski Katherine, Huth Nicole, Barnett Kierin, Sarmiento Natalie, Henkel Madeline, Shutts Kristin
University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Wake Forest University.
Dev Rev. 2025 Jun;76. doi: 10.1016/j.dr.2025.101189. Epub 2025 Mar 30.
In recent years, there have been accelerated efforts among developmental scientists to understand and address children's ethnic and racial attitudes, stereotypes, and discrimination. For such efforts, using high-quality and context-appropriate measures is critical. However, focused discussions and investigations of measures for capturing children's ethnic and racial attitudes, stereotypes, and discrimination are scant. Accordingly, we conducted a systematic review of 1,001 measures that were used in 403 journal articles published between 2010 and 2022. Our review was guided by four questions: (1) What types of measures of children's ethnic and racial attitudes, stereotypes, and discrimination are being used by researchers?; (2) How do measures represent target groups?; (3) In which geographic and demographic contexts are measures being used?; and (4) What evidence do we have about some of the psychometric properties of commonly used scales/tasks? In seeking answers to these questions, we found both strengths and problems with our field's toolkit of measures. Taken together, our review provides an overview of modern measures for capturing children's ethnic and racial attitudes, stereotypes, and discrimination; offers initial insights about the characteristics and psychometric properties of those measures; and makes recommendations for future efforts in the field. We argue that measurement evaluation is a fertile avenue for future work in our field and that widespread discussions about measurement are necessary to advance the science of how children feel, think about, and behave toward members of different social groups.
近年来,发展科学家们加快了努力,以理解和解决儿童的种族和民族态度、刻板印象及歧视问题。对于这些努力而言,使用高质量且符合情境的测量方法至关重要。然而,针对用于捕捉儿童种族和民族态度、刻板印象及歧视的测量方法的深入讨论和调查却很少。因此,我们对2010年至2022年间发表在403篇期刊文章中使用的1001种测量方法进行了系统综述。我们的综述由四个问题引导:(1)研究人员使用了哪些类型的儿童种族和民族态度、刻板印象及歧视的测量方法?;(2)测量方法如何呈现目标群体?;(3)测量方法在哪些地理和人口背景下被使用?;(4)我们对常用量表/任务的一些心理测量特性有哪些证据?在寻求这些问题的答案时,我们发现了该领域测量方法工具包的优点和问题。总体而言,我们的综述概述了用于捕捉儿童种族和民族态度、刻板印象及歧视的现代测量方法;提供了关于这些测量方法的特征和心理测量特性的初步见解;并为该领域未来的工作提出了建议。我们认为,测量评估是我们领域未来工作的一个富有成果的途径,关于测量的广泛讨论对于推进关于儿童对不同社会群体成员的感受、思考和行为方式的科学研究是必要的。