Chen Qin, Ren Ningjun, Liu Shengya, Qian Zixin, Li Mengdie, Mustapha Aliyu, Luo Wei, Li Jinghua, Wang Wenxi, Hao Chun
Department of Medical Statistics, School of Public Health, Sun Yat-Sen University, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou, 510080, People's Republic of China.
Sun Yat-Sen Global Health Institute, Institute of State Governance | Institute of International and Regional Studies, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou, 510275, People's Republic of China.
Glob Health Res Policy. 2025 Jun 23;10(1):24. doi: 10.1186/s41256-025-00424-y.
Tuberculosis (TB) continues to pose a significant global public health threat, particularly among migrant populations. Screening policies exist in many receiving countries but differ markedly, and there is limited pooled evidence on TB and latent TB infection (LTBI) prevalence among migrants under different screening frameworks. This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to synthesize TB and LTBI prevalence among migrants and compared national screening policies to inform evidence-based public health planning.
PubMed, Embase, Web of Science and Cochrane Library were searched for studies published 2016-2023. Random-effects models generated pooled prevalence estimates with 95% CIs; subgroup analyses examined differences by screening stage, migrant category, and country-of-origin incidence. Sensitivity analyses tested robustness. Government and health-agency websites were systematically examined and scored to table national TB-screening requirements.
36 studies (26 TB, 21 LTBI) covering 40,738,331 migrants screened met inclusion criteria. The Pooled TB prevalence was 214.52/100,000 (95% CI 112.18-349.66) and LTBI prevalence 14.9% (95% CI 9.91-20.60). Countries employing both pre-entry screening and subsequent post-entry surveillance achieved the lowest TB prevalence (94.09/100,000). The highest burdens occurred among refugees/asylum seekers (439.25/100,000) and migrants from countries with TB incidence 300-499/100,000 (491.96/100,000). LTBI was most common when identified through post-entry screening (21.90%), those with multiple migrants (18.11%), and among migrants originating from countries with ≥ 500/100,000 TB incidence (30.90%). Policy comparison showed pre-entry screening is almost universal; the United States is the only country mandating systematic LTBI screening. Screening-scope scores were highest in traditional immigrant countries (16-20), intermediate in middle-income destinations such as China and Malaysia (10-14), and lowest in Nordic (4-8).
This study emphasizes the importance of targeted TB screening, especially for migrants from high-prevalence regions and at-risk populations. Comprehensive pre- and post-entry TB screening, along with strengthened latent TB screening and surveillance for diverse migrant populations, is essential. Meanwhile enhanced collaboration to update screening policies are key to achieving the goal of TB eradication and provide practical insights for effective TB control.
结核病(TB)仍然是全球重大的公共卫生威胁,在移民群体中尤为突出。许多接收国存在筛查政策,但差异显著,关于不同筛查框架下移民中结核病和潜伏性结核感染(LTBI)患病率的汇总证据有限。本系统评价和荟萃分析旨在综合移民中的结核病和LTBI患病率,并比较各国筛查政策,以为循证公共卫生规划提供依据。
检索了PubMed、Embase、Web of Science和Cochrane图书馆中2016年至2023年发表的研究。随机效应模型生成了95%置信区间的汇总患病率估计值;亚组分析按筛查阶段、移民类别和原籍国发病率检查差异。敏感性分析测试了稳健性。系统审查并评估了政府和卫生机构网站,以列出各国结核病筛查要求。
36项研究(26项关于结核病,21项关于LTBI)涵盖了40,738,331名接受筛查的移民,符合纳入标准。汇总的结核病患病率为214.52/100,000(95%置信区间112.18 - 349.66),LTBI患病率为14.9%(95%置信区间9.91 - 20.60)。采用入境前筛查和随后的入境后监测的国家结核病患病率最低(94.09/100,000)。最高负担出现在难民/寻求庇护者中(439.25/100,000)以及来自结核病发病率为300 - 499/100,000的国家的移民中(491.96/100,000)。通过入境后筛查发现LTBI最为常见(21.90%),有多名移民的人群中(18.11%),以及来自结核病发病率≥500/100,000的国家的移民中(30.90%)。政策比较显示,入境前筛查几乎普遍存在;美国是唯一强制进行系统性LTBI筛查的国家。传统移民国家的筛查范围得分最高((16 - 20)),中国和马来西亚等中等收入目的地国家居中((10 - 14)),北欧国家最低((4 - 8))。
本研究强调了针对性结核病筛查的重要性,特别是对于来自高流行地区的移民和高危人群。全面的入境前和入境后结核病筛查,以及加强对不同移民群体的潜伏性结核筛查和监测至关重要。同时,加强合作以更新筛查政策是实现消除结核病目标的关键,并为有效的结核病控制提供实际见解。