Gemmati Donato, Scarpellini Fabio, Salvatori Francesca, D'Aversa Elisabetta, Marci Roberto, Capucci Roberta, Antonica Bianca, Grisafi Miriana, Turato Elisa, Vargas Joanne Vanessa, Secchiero Paola, Zauli Giorgio, Singh Ajay V, Tisato Veronica
Department of Translational Medicine, University of Ferrara, 44121, Ferrara, Italy.
Centre Haemostasis & Thrombosis, University of Ferrara, 44121, Ferrara, Italy.
Clin Epigenetics. 2025 Jul 23;17(1):130. doi: 10.1186/s13148-025-01937-6.
Pregnancy loss is one of the most common adverse events during the first weeks of gestation, and the incidence increases with maternal age and in presence of selected risk factors. Nonetheless, no risk factors have been identified in most cases, considering these cases unexplained. Fertility rate decreases as maternal age increases and epigenetic age-dependent conditions may favor miscarriage. DNA methylation and telomere length are informative of aging and cell senescence, and their assessment has been evaluated as predictors of successful pregnancy.
Telomere length (TL; T/S) and LINE-1 methylation (LINE-1; %) have been assessed in a cohort of 242 pregnant women by comparing spontaneous early miscarriage (EPL, n = 129) with voluntary interruption (VPI, n = 113). Telomere size and LINE-1 methylation rate drastically decreased as the age of women increased (P < 0.000001) with EPL group having lower values (T/S: 322.6 ± 142.0 versus 455.0 ± 290.6; P < 0.000001 and LINE-1 %: 81.66 ± 4.2 versus 86.01 ± 3.7; P < 0.000001) also characterized by stronger age-dependent lowering compared to VPI (P = 0.00035 and P < 0.000001, respectively). A global improvement in TL was observed as LINE-1 methylation rate increased, and it was more evident in EPL than in VPI (P < 0.000001). Focusing on the area below the 25th percentile of TL and LINE-1 % distribution, an overrepresentation of EPL cases was observed (P < 0.000001). On the contrary, VPI controls were dramatically overrepresented (P < 0.000001) in the area above the respective 75th percentiles. The mutual comparison of the number of EPL and VPI in these two extreme areas (EPL/VPI = 3.12 versus EPL/VPI = 0.32) yielded a significant risk of early pregnancy failure when women carried both risk conditions, low TL and LINE-1 methylation (OR = 9.70, 3.94-23.72; P < 0.0001). The intracase analyses ascribed to recurrent EPL cases even higher risks (OR = 10.5, 3.6-29.5; P < 0.0001) and a risk dosage effect stratification recognized to low methylation highest odds than that of short telomeres (OR = 4.44, 2.45-8.03; P < 0.0001 and OR = 2.26, 1.26-4.04; P = 0.005, respectively).
Overall, this suggests a combined effect of short telomeres and low methylation in phenotype worsening and a significant role of methylation in sustaining telomere size. These data support the hypothesis that different levels of DNA methylation may capture different biological mechanisms underlying telomere dynamics and dysfunctions and chromatin organization. Therefore, the concomitant assessment of telomere, methylation and their mutual interactions may be a novel strategy to translate the classical informative biomarkers of aging in the field of human reproduction.
妊娠丢失是妊娠最初几周最常见的不良事件之一,其发生率随母亲年龄增加以及存在特定风险因素而上升。尽管如此,在大多数情况下尚未发现风险因素,这些情况被视为不明原因。随着母亲年龄增加生育率下降,且表观遗传年龄依赖性状况可能有利于流产。DNA甲基化和端粒长度可反映衰老和细胞衰老情况,其评估已被视为成功妊娠的预测指标。
通过比较自然早期流产(EPL,n = 129)与人工流产(VPI,n = 113),对242名孕妇队列的端粒长度(TL;T/S)和LINE-1甲基化(LINE-1;%)进行了评估。随着女性年龄增加,端粒大小和LINE-1甲基化率急剧下降(P < 0.000001),EPL组数值更低(T/S:322.6 ± 142.0 对比 455.0 ± 290.6;P < 0.000001,LINE-1 %:81.66 ± 4.2 对比 86.01 ± 3.7;P < 0.000001),与VPI相比,其年龄依赖性下降也更明显(分别为P = 0.00035和P < 0.000001)。随着LINE-1甲基化率增加,观察到TL整体有所改善,且在EPL中比在VPI中更明显(P < 0.000001)。关注TL和LINE-1 %分布第25百分位数以下区域,观察到EPL病例过多(P < 0.000001)。相反,VPI对照组在各自第75百分位数以上区域显著过多(P < 0.000001)。这两个极端区域中EPL和VPI数量的相互比较(EPL/VPI = 3.12对比EPL/VPI = 0.32)显示,当女性同时存在端粒短和LINE-1甲基化低这两种风险状况时,早期妊娠失败风险显著(OR = 9.70,3.94 - 23.72;P < 0.0001)。对复发性EPL病例的病例内分析显示风险甚至更高(OR = 10.5,3.6 - 29.5;P < 0.0001),风险剂量效应分层显示低甲基化的优势比高于短端粒(分别为OR = 4.44,2.45 - 8.03;P < 0.0001和OR = 2.26,1.26 - 4.04;P = 0.005)。
总体而言,这表明短端粒和低甲基化在表型恶化方面存在联合作用,且甲基化在维持端粒大小方面具有重要作用。这些数据支持这样的假设,即不同水平的DNA甲基化可能反映端粒动态和功能障碍以及染色质组织背后的不同生物学机制。因此,同时评估端粒、甲基化及其相互作用可能是在人类生殖领域将经典的衰老信息生物标志物转化应用的一种新策略。