Unal Derya, Demir Semra, Işik Sacide Rana, Olgaç Müge, Coşkun Raif, Terzioğlu Kadriye, Ersoy Ramazan, Beyaz Şengül, Öztop Nida, Tüzer Can, Yeğit Osman Ozan, Karsli Seda, Işsever Halim, Gelincik Asli, Çolakoğlu Bahattin, Büyüköztürk Suna
Division of Immunology and Allergy Diseases, Internal Medicine Department, Istanbul Faculty of Medicine, Istanbul University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Division of Immunology and Allergy Diseases, Yedikule Chest Diseases and Thoracic Surgery Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey.
World Allergy Organ J. 2025 Aug 9;18(8):101101. doi: 10.1016/j.waojou.2025.101101. eCollection 2025 Aug.
We aimed to assess knowledge of emergency department (ED) physicians regarding the classification and treatment of angioedema and to evaluate the impact of a training program on this knowledge base.
A total of 11 questions about angioedema and its types were posed to ED physicians from various hospitals, either in person or via e-mail, before the implementation of an educational module on the subject (pre-test). Following a brief training period, the ED physicians were presented with the same set of questions once again (post-test). The reliability between the repeated tests were estimated using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Item difficulty was calculated separately for each question in both the pre-test and post-test.
A total of 541 ED physicians participated in the pre-test survey, and 162 of them declined to participate in the post-test survey. The remaining 379 participated in the post-test survey as well. The ICC between the repeated tests indicated a moderate level of reliability (mean ICC = 0.5; 0.42-0.57; lower and upper 95% confidence intervals). The mean item difficulty was 0.36 in the pre-test, indicating that the items had an appropriate level of difficulty. In the post-test, the mean item difficulty increased to 0.57, suggesting that the items were generally easier, likely reflecting improved knowledge or skills following the intervention. The level of knowledge regarding the clinical features of different types of angioedema was found to be inadequate. Following the training period, there was a notable increase in the number of correct answers, with a statistically significant difference (p = 0.002). Similarly, a remarkable increase was observed in the number of respondents who indicated that bradykinin-mediated-angioedema should be considered in cases of unresponsiveness to antihistamine and-corticosteroid treatment (p < 0.001). Regarding queries about hereditary angioedema (HAE), the majority of ED physicians had no prior experience in treating a patient with HAE, and only a small number were familiar with the symptoms of HAE. Following the training ED physicians demonstrated enhanced knowledge of HAE symptoms and diagnostic criteria (p < 0.001). Similarly, a notable enhancement in familiarity with HAE attack treatments was observed when the inquiries related to these treatments were compared between the pre-test and post-test phases (p < 0.001).
In light of the potential lethality of attacks mediated by bradykinin, a training program should include the recognition of rare types of angioedema, with a particular emphasis on HAE disease.
我们旨在评估急诊科医生关于血管性水肿的分类和治疗的知识,并评估一项培训计划对该知识基础的影响。
在实施关于该主题的教育模块之前(预测试),通过面对面或电子邮件的方式,向来自不同医院的急诊科医生提出了总共11个关于血管性水肿及其类型的问题。经过短暂的培训期后,再次向急诊科医生提出相同的一组问题(后测试)。使用组内相关系数(ICC)估计重复测试之间的可靠性。分别计算预测试和后测试中每个问题的项目难度。
共有541名急诊科医生参与了预测试调查,其中162人拒绝参与后测试调查。其余379人也参与了后测试调查。重复测试之间的ICC表明可靠性处于中等水平(平均ICC = 0.5;0.42 - 0.57;95%置信区间下限和上限)。预测试中平均项目难度为0.36,表明这些项目具有适当的难度水平。在后测试中,平均项目难度增加到0.57,这表明这些项目总体上更容易,可能反映了干预后知识或技能的提高。发现关于不同类型血管性水肿临床特征的知识水平不足。经过培训期后,正确答案的数量显著增加,具有统计学显著差异(p = 0.002)。同样,在那些表示在对抗组胺药和皮质类固醇治疗无反应的病例中应考虑缓激肽介导的血管性水肿的受访者数量上观察到显著增加(p < 0.001)。关于遗传性血管性水肿(HAE)的询问,大多数急诊科医生此前没有治疗HAE患者的经验,只有少数人熟悉HAE的症状。经过培训后,急诊科医生对HAE症状和诊断标准的知识有所增强(p < 0.001)。同样,当比较预测试和后测试阶段与这些治疗相关的询问时,观察到对HAE发作治疗的熟悉程度有显著提高(p < 0.001)。
鉴于缓激肽介导的发作具有潜在致死性,培训计划应包括对罕见类型血管性水肿的识别,尤其要强调HAE疾病。