Zhang Yiran Vanessa
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Yale J Biol Med. 2025 Sep 30;98(3):349-355. doi: 10.59249/BIAS7665. eCollection 2025 Sep.
This paper focuses on the rise and fall of the Utica State Hospital, Utica, New York, once known for its pioneering use of moral treatment, as an example of how psychiatric institutionalization shaped ideas about mental illness, disability, and patient rights in America. Through architecture, patient narratives, and managerial reports, the paper explores how the institute ultimately fell out of use and how institutionalization, even with good intentions, could reinforce exclusion and harm toward the mentally ill and the disabled. The paper further traces the resonance between this legacy and today's psychiatric and disability studies, drawing attention to the recurring societal impulse to define and segregate abnormality.
本文聚焦于纽约尤蒂卡州立医院的兴衰,该医院曾以率先采用精神治疗法而闻名,以此为例阐述了精神病院制度化如何塑造了美国关于精神疾病、残疾及患者权利的观念。通过建筑、患者叙述及管理报告,本文探究了该机构最终为何不再被使用,以及制度化即便初衷良好,如何仍会强化对精神病患者和残疾人的排斥与伤害。本文进一步追溯了这一遗产与当今精神病学及残疾研究之间的共鸣,提请人们注意社会上反复出现的界定和隔离异常情况的冲动。