Belforte G, Bona B, Milanese M
Crit Rev Biomed Eng. 1984;10(4):275-316.
This paper will be devoted to demonstrating that a better understanding of complex metabolic processes requires a deep and reliable interpretation of much experimental data. Indeed this aim cannot be satisfied without the use of advanced modeling and identification techniques and their deep critical analysis. In fact, complete procedures should consider all the following steps: (1) definition of scopes, (2) prior information and hypotheses, (3) choice of experimental conditions, (4) derivation of possible classes of models, (5) parameter estimation, (6) errors evaluation, (7) validation and ordering of the identified models. This paper will mainly consider steps 4, 6, and 7 which are certainly the less assessed ones. However some real advances have been obtained in recent years which deserve to be more widely known and applied in practical problems. This paper will review such important contributions and will show, by means of applied examples, how they can be useful in avoiding ambiguities and incorrect interpretation of data and in evaluating the credibility of the inferred results.
本文将致力于证明,要更好地理解复杂的代谢过程,需要对大量实验数据进行深入且可靠的解读。事实上,如果不使用先进的建模和识别技术及其深入的批判性分析,这一目标就无法实现。实际上,完整的程序应考虑以下所有步骤:(1)范围定义;(2)先验信息和假设;(3)实验条件的选择;(4)可能的模型类别推导;(5)参数估计;(6)误差评估;(7)已识别模型的验证和排序。本文将主要考虑步骤4、6和7,这些步骤无疑是评估较少的步骤。然而,近年来已经取得了一些实际进展,值得更广泛地了解并应用于实际问题中。本文将回顾这些重要贡献,并通过应用实例展示它们如何有助于避免数据的模糊性和错误解读,以及评估推断结果的可信度。