Ashton B B, Pickles B, Roll J W
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1978 Feb;20(1):87-94. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.1978.tb15184.x.
Reliability of goniometric measurements of ranges of motion in the right hip of four children with mild or moderate spastic diplegia was studied by comparing results when physical therapists used specific and non-specific measurement instructions. Measurements of hip extension, abduction and external rotation were made. The use of specific measurement instructions improved inter-rater reliability only in the case of external rotation. Inter-session reliability was not improved by the use of specific measurement instructions. It is concluded that goniometric measurements have such a low level of reliability that they can only be used to assist clinical judgment, and that they are not sufficiently reliable to be used in studied of cerebral palsy.
通过比较物理治疗师使用特定和非特定测量指导时的结果,研究了四名轻度或中度痉挛性双侧瘫患儿右髋活动范围的测角测量的可靠性。进行了髋关节伸展、外展和外旋的测量。仅在进行外旋测量时,使用特定测量指导提高了评估者间的可靠性。使用特定测量指导并未提高测量期间的可靠性。得出的结论是,测角测量的可靠性水平很低,只能用于辅助临床判断,并且其可靠性不足以用于脑瘫研究。