Bolton D, Leichner P
Can J Psychiatry. 1984 Dec;29(8):700-3. doi: 10.1177/070674378402900812.
Presently in Canada the value of the straight internship in psychiatry and the need for a mandatory rotation in psychiatry during a rotating internship are sources of active debate between the licensing bodies and psychiatric programs and organizations. The importance of the internship as it pertains to the total psychiatric education process has been discussed in a number of research articles from the United States. The conclusions from these studies range from recommendations that rotating internships be discontinued because they may cause empathic blunting among trainees, to strong endorsements of its necessity. The present study examined residents' and residency directors' views of the types of internships in Canada. One hundred and ninety-nine residents and thirteen residency directors completed a questionnaire in 1980. The majority of residents (74.3%) and residency directors (77%) felt that the rotating-mixed internship should be a requirement prior to taking post-graduate training in psychiatry. Most also felt that this type of internship should contain a mandatory one to two months psychiatry rotation. Opinions on the value of the straight internship in psychiatry were mixed for both residents and residency directors. Statistical analyses were carried out comparing the opinions of residents having had a rotating internship versus those having had a straight internship: foreign medical graduates (FMG's) versus Canadian medical graduates (CMG's); and male versus female. As would be expected, the residents who had previously completed a straight internship favoured this type of internship and were more critical of the rotating type.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
目前在加拿大,精神病学直接实习的价值以及在轮转实习期间进行精神病学强制轮转的必要性,是执照颁发机构与精神病学项目及组织之间激烈争论的焦点。在美国的一些研究文章中已经讨论了实习对于整个精神病学教育过程的重要性。这些研究的结论各不相同,从建议停止轮转实习,因为它们可能导致实习生出现共情钝化,到强烈支持其必要性。本研究调查了加拿大住院医师和住院医师培训主任对实习类型的看法。199名住院医师和13名住院医师培训主任在1980年完成了一份调查问卷。大多数住院医师(74.3%)和住院医师培训主任(77%)认为,在接受精神病学研究生培训之前,轮转 - 混合实习应该是一项要求。大多数人还认为,这种实习应该包含一到两个月的精神病学强制轮转。住院医师和住院医师培训主任对精神病学直接实习的价值看法不一。对曾有过轮转实习的住院医师与曾有过直接实习的住院医师的意见进行了统计分析比较:外国医学毕业生(FMG)与加拿大医学毕业生(CMG);以及男性与女性。不出所料,之前完成过直接实习的住院医师更青睐这种实习类型,并且对轮转类型更为挑剔。(摘要截取自250词)