Gibbons J S, Butler J, Urwin P, Gibbons J L
Br J Psychiatry. 1978 Aug;133:111-8. doi: 10.1192/bjp.133.2.111.
Four hundred patients aged at least 17 who came to Casualty in one year after deliberately poisoning themselves were randomly assigned between an Experimental social work service (task-centered casework) and a Control (routine) follow-up service. 139 patients were excluded from the trial, most of whom were already in continuing psychiatric treatment. After one year there was no difference in the proportions of E and C patients who repeated self-poisoning (about 14 per cent), but significantly more of the excluded group had repeated (36 per cent). A random half of the trial patients were re-interviewed four months after admission. Both E and C groups had improved to a significant extent on measures of depressed mood and of social problems. E patients showed more change in social problems and were more satisfied with the service they had received.
400名年龄至少17岁、在故意中毒后一年内前来急诊的患者被随机分配到实验性社会工作服务组(以任务为中心的个案工作)和对照组(常规)随访服务组。139名患者被排除在试验之外,其中大多数已经在接受持续的精神治疗。一年后,实验组和对照组中再次自我中毒的患者比例没有差异(约14%),但被排除组中再次自我中毒的比例明显更高(36%)。随机抽取一半的试验患者在入院四个月后接受再次访谈。实验组和对照组在抑郁情绪和社会问题测量方面都有显著改善。实验组患者在社会问题方面变化更大,对所接受的服务也更满意。