Bastianello S, Gasperini C, Ristori G, Paolillo A, Girmenia F, Bozzao L
Dipartimento di Scienze Neurologiche, Università di Roma, La Sapienza.
Radiol Med. 1994 Dec;88(6):749-51.
This study was aimed at investigating the value of MRI in the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. In the Multiple Sclerosis Center of our University, we sorted out of the patients submitted to CSF and MR examinations, only those with clinically unquestionable multiple sclerosis, white matter abnormalities at MRI and normal CSF examination. These 21 patients were submitted to CSF and MRI examinations which were repeated whenever required if image quality was technically suboptimal; a variety of screening tests for different diseases mimicking multiple sclerosis were also performed. In 4 patients with white matter abnormalities at MRI which were considered atypical for multiple sclerosis, at image rereading and after laboratory tests the diagnosis were: coagulopathy, sarcoidosis, vasculitis and CNS lymphoma. In 2 cases with questionable white matter abnormalities at MRI, the final diagnosis were borreliosis and vasculitis. The remaining 15 patients had a diagnosis of multiple sclerosis in all but 3 cases in which subsequent clinical and laboratory examinations demonstrated the presence of vasculitis, embolism from interatrial septal aneurysm and mitochondrial disease. Our study suggests that in the patients with clinical findings of multiple sclerosis and disseminated MR lesions mimicking multiple sclerosis, but no CSF abnormalities, the classical clinical criteria may not be sufficiently specific and other diagnoses must therefore be excluded before making an "unquestionable" diagnosis of multiple sclerosis.
本研究旨在探讨磁共振成像(MRI)在多发性硬化症诊断中的价值。在我校多发性硬化症中心,我们从接受脑脊液和MRI检查的患者中筛选出仅那些临床诊断明确为多发性硬化症、MRI显示白质异常且脑脊液检查正常的患者。这21例患者接受了脑脊液和MRI检查,若图像质量在技术上欠佳,则根据需要重复检查;还对多种模仿多发性硬化症的不同疾病进行了一系列筛查测试。在4例MRI显示白质异常但被认为不符合多发性硬化症典型表现的患者中,经图像重新解读和实验室检查后,诊断分别为:凝血障碍、结节病、血管炎和中枢神经系统淋巴瘤。在2例MRI显示白质异常情况存疑的患者中,最终诊断为莱姆病和血管炎。其余15例患者除3例在后续临床和实验室检查中发现存在血管炎、房间隔动脉瘤栓塞和线粒体疾病外,均被诊断为多发性硬化症。我们的研究表明,对于有多发性硬化症临床表现且MRI显示类似多发性硬化症的播散性病变但脑脊液无异常的患者,经典的临床标准可能不够特异,因此在做出“明确”的多发性硬化症诊断之前,必须排除其他诊断。