Mendez M F, Doss R C, Taylor J L
Department of Neurology, St. Paul-Ramsey Medical Center-University of Minnesota 55101.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1993 Sep;181(9):566-9. doi: 10.1097/00005053-199309000-00007.
Interictal violence among epileptic patients could result from factors other than epileptiform activity. We characterized 44 patients who presented for psychiatric evaluation because of violent behavior. Most violent acts consisted of verbal or minor physical aggression. Twenty (45%) of these patients met criteria for a schizophrenic disorder, and one committed murder during a paranoid schizophrenic relapse. In addition to schizophrenia, the violence patients had significantly more mental retardation when compared with 88 age- and sex-matched epileptic patients without prior violent behavior. However, violent and nonviolent patients did not differ on seizure variables such as type and frequency of seizures, auras, electroencephalographic changes, epilepsy age of onset, or anticonvulsant therapy. These findings suggest that interictal violence is associated more with psychopathology and mental retardation than with epileptiform activity or other seizure variables.
癫痫患者发作间期的暴力行为可能由癫痫样活动以外的因素引起。我们对44名因暴力行为前来接受精神科评估的患者进行了特征分析。大多数暴力行为包括言语攻击或轻微身体攻击。其中20名(45%)患者符合精神分裂症障碍的标准,1名患者在偏执型精神分裂症复发期间实施了谋杀。除精神分裂症外,与88名年龄和性别匹配、无暴力行为史的癫痫患者相比,暴力行为患者的智力发育迟缓更为明显。然而,暴力行为患者和非暴力行为患者在癫痫发作变量方面并无差异,如发作类型和频率、先兆、脑电图变化、癫痫发病年龄或抗惊厥治疗情况。这些发现表明,发作间期的暴力行为与精神病理学和智力发育迟缓的关联更大,而非与癫痫样活动或其他癫痫发作变量相关。