Maizels M, Scott B, Cohen W, Chen W
Department of Family Practice, Southern California Permanente Medical Group, Woodland Hills, CA 91365, USA.
JAMA. 1996;276(4):319-21.
To evaluate the effectiveness of intranasal lidocaine for treatment of acute migraine headache.
Prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial.
Community urgent care department.
A total of 81 patients (67 women and 14 men; median age, 42 years; range, 19-68 years) with a chief complaint of headache who fulfilled criteria of the International Headache Society for migraine participated. Patients were excluded if headache had lasted more than 3 days or if the frequency of severe headache was more than once per week.
Patients were randomized in a 2:1 ratio to receive a 4 percent solution of intranasal lidocaine or saline placebo, respectively.
The primary outcome measure was at least 50 percent reduction of headache within 15 minutes after treatment. Secondary measures include reduction in nausea and photophobia, use of rescue medication, relapse of headache, and change in headache disability scores.
Of 53 patients who received intranasal lidocaine, 29 (55 percent) had at least a 50 percent reduction of headache compared with 6 (21 percent) of 28 controls (P=.004). Nausea and photophobia were significantly reduced (P=.03 and P=.001, respectively). Rescue medication for headache relief was needed in 15 (28 percent) of 53 patients in the lidocaine group vs 20 (71 percent) of 28 controls (P<.001). Among those with initial relief of headache, relapse of headache occurred in 10 (42 percent) of 24 in the lidocaine group vs 5 (83 percent) of 6 in the control group (P=.17), usually within the first hour after treatment.
Intranasal lidocaine provides rapid relief of headache in approximately 55 percent of ambulatory patients with migraine. Relapse of headache is common and occurs early after treatment.
评估鼻内利多卡因治疗急性偏头痛的有效性。
前瞻性、随机、双盲、安慰剂对照试验。
社区紧急护理部门。
共有81例以头痛为主诉且符合国际头痛协会偏头痛标准的患者(67例女性和14例男性;中位年龄42岁;范围19 - 68岁)参与。若头痛持续超过3天或严重头痛频率超过每周一次,则排除该患者。
患者按2:1比例随机分组,分别接受4%的鼻内利多卡因溶液或生理盐水安慰剂。
主要观察指标为治疗后15分钟内头痛减轻至少50%。次要指标包括恶心和畏光症状的减轻、急救药物的使用、头痛复发情况以及头痛残疾评分的变化。
53例接受鼻内利多卡因治疗的患者中,29例(55%)头痛减轻至少50%,而28例对照组患者中有6例(21%)头痛减轻至少50%(P = 0.004)。恶心和畏光症状显著减轻(分别为P = 0.03和P = 0.001)。利多卡因组53例患者中有15例(28%)需要使用急救药物缓解头痛,而对照组28例患者中有20例(71%)需要使用(P < 0.001)。在最初头痛缓解的患者中,利多卡因组24例中有10例(42%)头痛复发,对照组6例中有5例(83%)头痛复发(P = 0.17),通常在治疗后第一小时内复发。
鼻内利多卡因可使约55%的门诊偏头痛患者头痛迅速缓解。头痛复发常见且在治疗后早期发生。