Lewallen D G, Cabanela M E
Mayo Clinic/Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1996 Dec(333):126-33.
One hundred fifty-two hips were reviewed at a minimum of 5 years after hybrid primary total hip arthroplasty using uncemented porous coated acetabular components and cemented femoral stems to determine the intermediate term durability of this method of fixation. Five hips (3.6%) have been revised: 1 for dislocation (0.7%), 1 for cup loosening (0.7%), and 3 for femoral loosening (2.2%). Clinical results proved to be extremely reliable in this series with 78% of the patients reporting no pain and 19.7% reporting slight or occasional pain. Radiographic evidence of polyethylene wear was evident in more than 1/2 of cups, but significant osteolysis or component loosening was not commonly seen on the cup side. On the femoral side incomplete radiolucencies were present in 31%, and focal osteolysis in 12.2%, nearly always proximally in Zones 1 and 7. These intermediate term results compare favorably on the femoral side and very favorably on the acetabular side to prior reported series. These results support the continued use of this combination of fixation methods for primary arthroplasty, but polyethylene wear and its effects remain a concern regarding the long term performance of these arthroplasties.
对采用非骨水泥多孔涂层髋臼组件和骨水泥股骨柄的混合初次全髋关节置换术后至少5年的152例髋关节进行了评估,以确定这种固定方法的中期耐用性。5例髋关节(3.6%)进行了翻修:1例因脱位(0.7%),1例因髋臼杯松动(0.7%),3例因股骨柄松动(2.2%)。在该系列中,临床结果被证明极其可靠,78%的患者报告无疼痛,19.7%的患者报告有轻微或偶尔疼痛。超过一半的髋臼杯有聚乙烯磨损的影像学证据,但髋臼侧通常未见明显的骨溶解或组件松动。在股骨侧,31%存在不完全透光线,12.2%存在局灶性骨溶解,几乎都位于近端的1区和7区。与先前报道的系列相比,这些中期结果在股骨侧比较有利,在髋臼侧非常有利。这些结果支持继续将这种固定方法组合用于初次关节置换术,但聚乙烯磨损及其影响仍然是这些关节置换术长期性能的一个问题。