Mulliken B D, Rorabeck C H, Bourne R B
University Hospital, University of Western Ontario, London, Canada.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1996 Apr(325):156-62. doi: 10.1097/00003086-199604000-00017.
A review of 52 cementless revision total hip arthroplasties in 51 patients with a 4- to 6-year clinical and radiographic followup was conducted. Mallory Head titanium alloy prostheses using proximally porous-coated femoral stems were used in all cases. There were 2 revisions of the femoral component only and 1 was an acetabular revision. At an average followup of 4.6 years, 5 (10%) unstable femoral stems had been rerevised and another 7 (14%) stems were unstable radiographically, but rerevision had been refused or postponed. Three (6%) sockets were considered unstable but no acetabular revisions have been done. Eleven of the 12 stem failures were in femora with moderate or severe prerevision femoral bone loss. The Harris Hip Score averaged 76 points for the entire group, and scores were much worse in patients with preexisting femoral bone deficiency. Twenty (40%) femoral fractures occurred during stem insertion. This short-term study shows inadequate fixation of proximally porous-coated femoral stems in revisions with femoral bone loss; adequate stability is achieved if bone loss is limited. Porous-coated acetabular fixation using fins and screws where necessary is adequate in the majority of cases.
对51例患者的52例非骨水泥型全髋关节翻修术进行了回顾性研究,临床和影像学随访时间为4至6年。所有病例均使用近端多孔涂层股骨柄的马洛里海德钛合金假体。仅对股骨部件进行了2次翻修,1次为髋臼翻修。平均随访4.6年时,有5例(10%)不稳定股骨柄进行了再次翻修,另有7例(14%)股骨柄在影像学上不稳定,但患者拒绝或推迟了再次翻修。3例(6%)髋臼杯被认为不稳定,但尚未进行髋臼翻修。12例股骨柄失败中有11例发生在翻修前有中度或重度股骨骨质流失的股骨中。全组Harris髋关节评分平均为76分,在已有股骨骨质缺损的患者中评分更差。20例(40%)股骨骨折发生在股骨柄植入过程中。这项短期研究表明,在伴有股骨骨质流失的翻修术中,近端多孔涂层股骨柄固定不充分;如果骨质流失有限,则可实现足够的稳定性。在大多数情况下,必要时使用鳍片和螺钉进行多孔涂层髋臼固定是足够的。