Wieselgren I M, Lindström E, Lindström L H
Department of Psychiatry, Ulleråker, University Hospital, Uppsala, Sweden.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1996 Nov;94(5):311-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1996.tb09866.x.
A total of 107 drug-free schizophrenic patients (76 males and 31 females) were consecutively admitted to an emergency ward and rated for psychotic symptoms by means of 32 items from the Comprehensive Psychopathological Rating Scale (CPRS). They were followed prospectively with ratings of social functioning by use of Strauss-Carpenter's outcome scale at 1, 3 and 5 years after index admission with the aim of determining possible early symptoms that are predictors of social outcome. In total, 59 of the patients were first admissions and had never been treated. At index admission, no difference was found in total CPRS scores between first-admission patients and chronic readmitted patients, or between male and female subjects. When subscales for positive symptoms (flights of ideas, feeling controlled, disrupted thoughts, auditory hallucinations, ideas of persecution) and negative symptoms (indecision, withdrawal, reduced speech, lack of appropriate emotions, slowness of movements) from the CPRS were applied, no relationship between the two subscales and outcome scores was found. However, in patients with a duration of the disorder of less than 24 months before index admission, high scores on both negative and positive subscales were significantly correlated with a poor 5-year outcome. No correlation was found in the group with a duration of illness of more than 24 months before index admission. It is concluded that symptoms at index admission have a predictive value for outcome in schizophrenic patients. Negative symptoms measured by use of a subscale of the CPRS have a predictive value for outcome up to 5 years after index admission, but high scores on both positive and negative symptoms are more strongly associated with a poor outcome. The duration of the symptoms before admission, as well as the kind of neuroleptic treatment given (clozapine vs. classical neuroleptics), seem to be important factors for prediction of outcome. Our data support the view that early negative symptoms in particular have a predictive value for the prognosis in schizophrenia for up to 5 years.
共有107名未服用药物的精神分裂症患者(76名男性和31名女性)连续入住急诊病房,并通过综合精神病理学评定量表(CPRS)的32个项目对其精神病症状进行评定。在首次入院后的1年、3年和5年,使用施特劳斯-卡彭特结局量表对他们的社会功能进行前瞻性评定,目的是确定可能作为社会结局预测指标的早期症状。总共有59名患者是首次入院,从未接受过治疗。在首次入院时,首次入院患者与慢性再入院患者之间,以及男性和女性受试者之间,CPRS总分没有差异。当应用CPRS中的阳性症状(思维奔逸、被控制感、思维紊乱、幻听、被害妄想)和阴性症状(犹豫不决、退缩、言语减少、缺乏适当情感、动作迟缓)分量表时,未发现这两个分量表与结局分数之间存在关联。然而,在首次入院前疾病持续时间少于24个月的患者中,阴性和阳性分量表的高分与5年不良结局显著相关。在首次入院前疾病持续时间超过24个月的组中未发现相关性。得出的结论是,首次入院时的症状对精神分裂症患者的结局具有预测价值。使用CPRS分量表测量的阴性症状对首次入院后长达5年的结局具有预测价值,但阳性和阴性症状的高分与不良结局的关联更强。入院前症状的持续时间以及给予的抗精神病药物治疗类型(氯氮平与传统抗精神病药物)似乎是结局预测的重要因素。我们的数据支持这样一种观点,即特别是早期阴性症状对精神分裂症长达5年的预后具有预测价值。