Kanis J A, McCloskey E V
World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for Metabolic Bone Diseases, Department of Human Metabolism and Clinical Biochemistry, University of Sheffield Medical School, United Kingdom.
Cancer. 1997 Oct 15;80(8 Suppl):1691-5. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1097-0142(19971015)80:8+<1691::aid-cncr21>3.3.co;2-3.
Clodronate is a second-generation bisphosphonate of intermediate potency between etidronate and aminobisphosphonates. It is an effective inhibitor of bone resorption, but unlike etidronate does not impair the mineralization of bone. Unlike pamidronate, it can be given both intravenously and orally. There is wide experience in the use of clodronate in the management of patients of hypercalcemia. The most widely used therapeutic regimen is 300 mg intravenously repeated for 5 days or a single infusion of 1500 mg. Efficacy is nearly complete in patients with myelomatosis, less complete in solid tumors with hypercalcemia but without skeletal metastases, and intermediate in patients with solid tumors in the presence of skeletal metastases. Variations in effect appear to be due to differences in renal tubular reabsorption of calcium between the three disorders. Placebo-controlled studies examining the effects of clodronate on bone pain in the absence of hypercalcemia have shown significant decreases in the severity of bone pain. These findings, coupled with the knowledge that suppression of bone resorption persists for the duration of treatment, has led to the long term use of oral doses of clodronate to decrease the incidence of complications of osteolytic bone disease. The long term control of bone resorption with oral clodronate has been demonstrated by double blind histologic studies. The ultimate arbiter of the value of clodronate is whether it decreases the skeletal morbidity associated with osteolysis. Double blind prospective controlled studies suggest that the incidence of bone pain, fracture, and hypercalcemia can be decreased significantly in patients with breast carcinoma. In addition, the use of long term clodronate in patients with myelomatosis significantly decreases the progression of osteolytic bone lesions, the risk of fractures, and the incidence of hypercalcemia. These studies have raised the possibility that bone disease might be prevented in individuals at high risk. Double blind prospective studies in women with recurrent breast carcinoma but no evidence of skeletal metastases showed a small effect of clodronate in decreasing the proportion of women developing metastatic disease. However, there was a large and significant decrease in the number of skeletal metastases associated with a decrease in skeletal morbidity. These observations suggest that clodronate may modify the natural history of the expression of skeletal disease, and thereby significantly improve the quality of life of affected patients.
氯膦酸盐是第二代双膦酸盐,其效力介于依替膦酸盐和氨基双膦酸盐之间。它是一种有效的骨吸收抑制剂,但与依替膦酸盐不同,它不会损害骨矿化。与帕米膦酸盐不同,它既可以静脉给药也可以口服给药。在使用氯膦酸盐治疗高钙血症患者方面有丰富的经验。最广泛使用的治疗方案是静脉注射300mg,重复5天,或单次输注1500mg。在骨髓瘤患者中疗效几乎完全,在伴有高钙血症但无骨转移的实体瘤患者中疗效稍差,在伴有骨转移的实体瘤患者中疗效中等。疗效差异似乎是由于这三种疾病中肾小管对钙的重吸收不同所致。在无高钙血症的情况下,安慰剂对照研究考察氯膦酸盐对骨痛的影响,结果显示骨痛严重程度显著降低。这些发现,再加上已知在治疗期间骨吸收抑制持续存在,导致长期口服氯膦酸盐以降低溶骨性骨病并发症的发生率。口服氯膦酸盐对骨吸收的长期控制已通过双盲组织学研究得到证实。氯膦酸盐价值的最终评判标准是它是否能降低与骨溶解相关的骨骼发病率。双盲前瞻性对照研究表明,乳腺癌患者的骨痛、骨折和高钙血症发生率可显著降低。此外,在骨髓瘤患者中长期使用氯膦酸盐可显著降低溶骨性骨病变的进展、骨折风险和高钙血症的发生率。这些研究增加了在高危个体中预防骨病的可能性。对复发性乳腺癌但无骨转移证据的女性进行的双盲前瞻性研究表明,氯膦酸盐在降低发生转移性疾病女性比例方面有微小作用。然而,与骨骼发病率降低相关的是骨转移数量大幅显著减少。这些观察结果表明,氯膦酸盐可能改变骨骼疾病表达的自然病程,从而显著改善受影响患者的生活质量。