Damen J J, Exterkate R A, ten Cate J M
Department of Cariology Endodontology Pedodontology, Academic Centre for Dentistry Amsterdam (ACTA), The Netherlands.
Adv Dent Res. 1997 Nov;11(4):415-9. doi: 10.1177/08959374970110040601.
Transverse microradiography (TMR) of thin sections is the principal method for determining mineral changes in experimental lesions. Because it has become also the standard by which newly-developed methods are validated, demands on all steps of the procedure are high. Thin sections of enamel and dentin require high-precision cutting or lapping to preserve surface structures, but their different brittleness and elasticity preclude a uniform procedure. Image analysis permits the measurement of fine details at a micron scale, but because most studies are aimed at overall mineral changes, they are usually lost on broadening of the scan areas and averaging of experimental groups. Small errors in repositioning of the scan areas for repetitive measurements may yield distorted lesion profiles, while quantitative data such as the integrated mineral loss are hardly influenced. A major reason for "irreproducibility" of TMR are the different definitions of the lesion parameters as used by various research groups. We recommend that these definitions be agreed on if the full potential of TMR as an international standard is to be utilized.
薄切片的横向显微放射照相术(TMR)是确定实验性病变中矿物质变化的主要方法。由于它也已成为验证新开发方法的标准,因此对该程序的所有步骤要求都很高。釉质和牙本质的薄切片需要高精度切割或研磨以保留表面结构,但它们不同的脆性和弹性排除了统一的程序。图像分析允许在微米尺度上测量精细细节,但由于大多数研究针对的是整体矿物质变化,它们通常会在扫描区域扩大和实验组平均化过程中丢失。重复测量时扫描区域重新定位的小误差可能会产生扭曲的病变轮廓,而诸如综合矿物质损失等定量数据几乎不受影响。TMR“不可重复性”的一个主要原因是各个研究小组使用的病变参数定义不同。我们建议,如果要充分发挥TMR作为国际标准的潜力,就应就这些定义达成一致。