Daniel Y, Fait G, Lessing J B, Jaffa A, David M P, Kupferminc M J
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology A, Lis Maternity Hospital, Sackler School of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Israel.
Am J Perinatol. 1998 Feb;15(2):97-101. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-993906.
The study was conducted to compare the neonatal and maternal outcome of breech infants delivered vaginally at term with those delivered by cesarean section. All singleton term breech deliveries between January 1, 1992 and December 31, 1994 were reviewed (n = 496). Criteria for eligibility for vaginal trial of labor included: frank or complete breech presentation, estimated fetal weight of 2000-3800 g, no hyperextension of the fetal head and no history of uterine scar (group A, n = 283). Patients who did not fulfill these criteria, or had an abnormal pelvimetry, were delivered by cesarean section without a trial of labor (group B, n = 213). In group A, 226 patients (80%) delivered vaginally, and 57 (20%) patients underwent a cesarean section; 70% of the nulliparae and 89% of the multiparae delivered vaginally. No differences were observed between the groups in gestational week, number of nulliparae, pregnancy complications, and rates of epidural analgesia. However, maternal age and birth weight were significantly higher in group B. No maternal or perinatal mortality occurred. The incidences of 5-min Apgar score <7, birth trauma, neonatal complications, and neonatal intensive care unit admissions were similar between the groups and in the nulliparae and multiparae of each group. Maternal morbidity was significantly lower in patients who delivered vaginally. We conclude that a trial of labor in breech presentation based on appropriate selective criteria, and an active policy of labor management performed by experienced physicians, will facilitate safe delivery in most nulliparae and multiparae.
本研究旨在比较足月臀位婴儿经阴道分娩与剖宫产分娩的新生儿及母亲结局。回顾了1992年1月1日至1994年12月31日期间所有单胎足月臀位分娩病例(n = 496)。阴道试产的入选标准包括:臀先露为单臀或完全臀先露、估计胎儿体重2000 - 3800 g、胎儿头部无过度伸展且无子宫瘢痕史(A组,n = 283)。不符合这些标准或骨盆测量异常的患者,未进行试产即行剖宫产(B组,n = 213)。A组中,226例患者(80%)经阴道分娩,57例患者(20%)行剖宫产;初产妇中70%经阴道分娩,经产妇中89%经阴道分娩。两组在孕周、初产妇数量、妊娠并发症及硬膜外镇痛率方面未观察到差异。然而,B组产妇年龄和出生体重显著更高。未发生孕产妇或围产儿死亡。两组之间以及每组的初产妇和经产妇中,5分钟阿氏评分<7、出生创伤、新生儿并发症及新生儿重症监护病房收治率的发生率相似。经阴道分娩患者的孕产妇发病率显著更低。我们得出结论,基于适当的选择标准进行臀位试产,并由经验丰富的医生实施积极的产程管理策略,将有助于大多数初产妇和经产妇实现安全分娩。