Thomson J G, Kim J H, Syed S A, Reid M A, Madsen J, Restifo R J
Section of Plastic Surgery and the Department of Surgical Pathology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06520-8041, USA.
Ann Plast Surg. 1998 Apr;40(4):436-41. doi: 10.1097/00000637-199804000-00019.
During free tissue transfer, an artery and one or two veins must be sutured. Either the artery or the vein can be repaired first, but the optimal order of vascular repair has not been established. Maintaining a clamp on a vessel is associated with vessel injury, and releasing the clamp may cause bleeding and vascular stasis. The purpose of this study was to determine if the order of vessel repair and the length of vascular clamping affects surgical outcome. Free flaps were created on Sprague-Dawley rats (400-450 g) as follows: Bilateral abdominal skin flaps (3 x 3 cm) based on the superficial inferior epigastric vessels were elevated. The femoral artery and vein were tied and divided distal to the branching of the inferior epigastric vessels. Proximal to the branching, the artery and vein were divided. The animals were then randomized into four groups as follows: In group I (N=16), the artery was repaired and then the clamps were released to revascularize the flap. Venous stasis occurred as the vein was being repaired because of the venous clamp. In group II (N=15), the artery was repaired, but the clamp was maintained to prevent blood from coming in contact with the fresh arterial anastomosis and to prevent venous stasis. The vein was then repaired. In group III (N=15), the vein was repaired first but the venous clamp was not released until the artery was repaired. In group IV (N=15), the vein was repaired first and the clamps were released, allowing venous blood to contact the fresh anastomosis while the artery was being repaired. After final clamp removal, all anastomoses were assessed immediately for evidence of thrombosis. Five days postoperatively the skin flap was evaluated for evidence of necrosis and the anastomosis was inspected for evidence of late thrombosis. The anastomoses were resected for histopathological evaluation. Flap success was compared between groups using chi-squared analysis. Eleven of 16 flaps failed (69%) in group I, and 3 of 15 flaps failed (20%) in each of groups II, III, and IV. Statistical significance was reached in comparing group I with the other three groups (p < 0.01). All failures in group I were caused by immediate venous thrombosis. The other failures were secondary to arterial thrombosis. Histopathological analysis failed to demonstrate any differences between the groups. According to these results, arterial repair followed by clamp release prior to the completion of the venous repair results in a low success rate, probably secondary to venous stasis within the draining vein while the venous anastomosis is being completed. If the arterial repair is performed first, then it is recommended that the arterial clamp be maintained until the venous repair is completed. If the vein is repaired first, then it can be clamped or unclamped with similar results.
在游离组织移植过程中,必须缝合一条动脉和一或两条静脉。动脉或静脉均可先进行修复,但血管修复的最佳顺序尚未确定。对血管持续夹闭会导致血管损伤,而松开夹子可能会引起出血和血管淤滞。本研究的目的是确定血管修复顺序和血管夹闭时间是否会影响手术结果。在体重400 - 450克的Sprague-Dawley大鼠上制作游离皮瓣如下:掀起以腹壁浅血管为蒂的双侧腹部皮瓣(3×3厘米)。在腹壁下血管分支远端结扎并切断股动脉和静脉。在分支近端切断动脉和静脉。然后将动物随机分为四组:第一组(N = 16),先修复动脉,然后松开夹子使皮瓣再血管化。由于静脉夹闭,在修复静脉时出现静脉淤滞。第二组(N = 15),先修复动脉,但维持夹子夹闭以防止血液接触新鲜的动脉吻合口并防止静脉淤滞。然后修复静脉。第三组(N = 15),先修复静脉,但直到动脉修复完成才松开静脉夹。第四组(N = 15),先修复静脉并松开夹子,在修复动脉时允许静脉血接触新鲜的吻合口。在最终移除夹子后,立即评估所有吻合口有无血栓形成的迹象。术后5天评估皮瓣有无坏死迹象,并检查吻合口有无晚期血栓形成的迹象。切除吻合口进行组织病理学评估。使用卡方分析比较各组之间的皮瓣成功率。第一组16个皮瓣中有11个失败(69%),第二、三、四组每组15个皮瓣中有3个失败(20%)。将第一组与其他三组比较有统计学意义(p < 0.01)。第一组所有失败均由即刻静脉血栓形成所致。其他失败继发于动脉血栓形成。组织病理学分析未显示各组之间有任何差异。根据这些结果,在完成静脉修复之前先修复动脉然后松开夹子,成功率较低,可能是由于在完成静脉吻合时引流静脉内出现静脉淤滞所致。如果先进行动脉修复,那么建议在完成静脉修复之前维持动脉夹闭。如果先修复静脉,那么夹闭或不夹闭静脉结果相似。