Crompton R H, Savage R, Spears I R
Department of Human Anatomy and Cell Biology, University of Liverpool, UK.
Folia Primatol (Basel). 1998;69 Suppl 1:41-59. doi: 10.1159/000052698.
The high-cusped, almost tritubercular teeth of Bornean tarsiers are used to reduce a wide variety of animal food. Prey is characteristically consumed entire, no parts being discarded. This paper attempts to identify the dental characteristics which permit tarsiers to reduce food substrates with widely varying mechanical properties and to assess whether reduction of some substrates incurs greater costs for tarsiers. Finite elements stress analysis (FESA) modelling is used to compare the effectiveness of tarsier and human teeth in reducing three types of food substrate habitually reduced by both species. Bone is taken as the exemplar of strong, stiff substrates, skin as the exemplar of substrates low in both stiffness and strength, and tendon as the exemplar of low-stiffness but strong substrates. The parameters used to measure performance are the work that must be done to bring tensile stresses to the point where tensile failure will be initiated and the bite-force required to do so. Human molars perform best in reducing bone, and tarsier molars in reducing skin. Neither perform as well in reducing tendon. Blunt, bunodont human molars perform slightly better than the high-cusped molars of tarsiers in reducing bone, but tarsier molars perform much better than human molars in inducing failure in skin and are also considerably better in reducing tendon. While the reduction effectiveness of human molars is greatly affected by substrate properties, the high cusps of tarsier teeth enable them to reduce foodstuffs of widely differing properties reasonably well. Scaling factors undoubtedly influence selection for cusp height, since high cusps are a prerequisite of effective crack propagation in food substrates by small animals. Microwear features do not show a consistent pattern where striations are associated with surface-parallel loads but pitting with surface-normal loads (at least as modelled by FESA). However, FESA modelling of the magnitude of applied forces and relative food/tooth displacement during occlusion suggest that the type of wear found in different regions is governed by the combined influences of relative tooth/food displacement and food/tooth reaction force. Pitting is associated with low levels of food/tooth displacement but high levels of reaction force, striation with high levels of displacement but low levels of force, and stripping or gouging of enamel with high values of both displacement and reaction force.
婆罗洲跗猴的高尖、几乎呈三结节状的牙齿用于咬碎各种各样的动物性食物。猎物通常是整个被吞食,没有部分被丢弃。本文试图确定使跗猴能够咬碎具有广泛不同机械性能的食物底物的牙齿特征,并评估咬碎某些底物是否会给跗猴带来更高的成本。有限元应力分析(FESA)建模用于比较跗猴和人类牙齿在咬碎两种物种都习惯咬碎的三种食物底物方面的有效性。骨头被视为坚硬、刚性底物的范例,皮肤被视为刚度和强度都低的底物的范例,肌腱被视为低刚度但高强度底物的范例。用于衡量性能的参数是将拉应力提高到引发拉伸破坏点所需做的功以及这样做所需的咬合力。人类臼齿在咬碎骨头方面表现最佳,跗猴臼齿在咬碎皮肤方面表现最佳。在咬碎肌腱方面两者表现都不佳。钝的、丘形的人类臼齿在咬碎骨头方面比跗猴高尖臼齿略好,但跗猴臼齿在使皮肤破裂方面比人类臼齿好得多,在咬碎肌腱方面也明显更好。虽然人类臼齿的咬碎效果受底物性质的影响很大,但跗猴牙齿的高尖使它们能够较好地咬碎性质差异很大的食物。比例因子无疑会影响对牙尖高度的选择,因为高牙尖是小动物在食物底物中有效裂纹扩展的先决条件。微磨损特征没有显示出一致的模式,其中条纹与表面平行载荷相关,而凹坑与表面垂直载荷相关(至少如FESA建模所示)。然而,FESA对咬合过程中施加力的大小和相对食物/牙齿位移的建模表明,在不同区域发现的磨损类型受相对牙齿/食物位移和食物/牙齿反作用力的综合影响。凹坑与低水平的食物/牙齿位移但高水平的反作用力相关,条纹与高水平的位移但低水平的力相关,釉质的剥落或凿痕与位移和反作用力的高值相关。