Poli-Merol M L, Francois S, Pfliger F, Lefebvre F, Roussel B, Liehn J C, Daoud S
Service de Chirurgie Pédiatrique, American Memorial Hospital, Reims, France.
Eur J Pediatr Surg. 1998 Dec;8(6):339-42. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1071228.
108 children with repeated urinary tract infection were examined both with direct contrast cystography and radionuclide cystography. There was a good correlation between the two procedures in the majority of the cases (79), but in 21 cases, direct radionuclide cystography alone was positive and for 8 other children, direct contrast cystography showed a low-grade vesico-ureteric reflux even though radionuclide cystography was negative. When comparing the two procedures and taking into consideration the age of the patients we find that radionuclide cystography is more sensitive to detect vesico-ureteric reflux in the younger population (p < 0.02). This advantage is less clear for older children who more often present a low-grade reflux. Low radiation exposure is also a great advantage of radionuclide cystography, but anatomic definition is better with contrast cystography. It seems thus that the two procedures complement rather than rival each other. Their respective interest for evaluation of repeated urinary tract infection in children therefore depends on age, attain-ability of the procedure, and the possibility of a bladder or ureteral abnormality. Quite a few authors consider radionuclide cystography as at least as valid as contrast cystography, and even more sensitive. We have attempted to compare both procedures and to determine their respective role in repeated urinary tract infection exploration.
对108例复发性尿路感染患儿分别进行了直接对比膀胱造影和放射性核素膀胱造影检查。在大多数病例(79例)中,两种检查方法结果具有良好的相关性,但在21例中,仅放射性核素膀胱造影呈阳性,另有8例患儿,尽管放射性核素膀胱造影为阴性,但直接对比膀胱造影显示有轻度膀胱输尿管反流。比较这两种检查方法并考虑患者年龄后发现,放射性核素膀胱造影在较年轻人群中检测膀胱输尿管反流更为敏感(p<0.02)。对于年龄较大的儿童,这种优势不太明显,因为他们更常出现轻度反流。放射性核素膀胱造影的另一个巨大优势是辐射暴露低,但对比膀胱造影对解剖结构的显示更好。因此,这两种检查方法似乎是互补而非相互竞争的。它们各自在评估儿童复发性尿路感染中的价值因此取决于年龄、检查方法的可及性以及膀胱或输尿管异常的可能性。不少作者认为放射性核素膀胱造影至少与对比膀胱造影一样有效,甚至更敏感。我们试图比较这两种检查方法,并确定它们在复发性尿路感染检查中的各自作用。