Doughty Adam H, Richards Jerry B
Department of Psychology, West Virginia University, Morgantown 26506-6040, USA.
J Exp Anal Behav. 2002 Jul;78(1):17-30. doi: 10.1901/jeab.2002.78-17.
Experiment I investigated the effects of reinforcer magnitude on differential-reinforcement-of-low-rate (DRL) schedule performance in three phases. In Phase 1, two groups of rats (n = 6 and 5) responded under a DRI. 72-s schedule with reinforcer magnitudes of either 30 or 300 microl of water. After acquisition, the water amounts were reversed for each rat. In Phase 2, the effects of the same reinforcer magnitudes on DRL 18-s schedule performance were examined across conditions. In Phase 3, each rat responded unider a DR1. 18-s schedule in which the water amotnts alternated between 30 and 300 microl daily. Throughout each phase of Experiment 1, the larger reinforcer magnitude resulted in higher response rates and lower reinforcement rates. The peak of the interresponse-time distributions was at a lower value tinder the larger reinforcer magnitude. In Experiment 2, 3 pigeons responded under a DRL 20-s schedule in which reinforcer magnitude (1-s or 6-s access to grain) varied iron session to session. Higher response rates and lower reinforcement rates occurred tinder the longer hopper duration. These results demonstrate that larger reinforcer magnitudes engender less efficient DRL schedule performance in both rats and pigeons, and when reinforcer magnitude was held constant between sessions or was varied daily. The present results are consistent with previous research demonstrating a decrease in efficiency as a function of increased reinforcer magnituide tinder procedures that require a period of time without a specified response. These findings also support the claim that DRI. schedule performance is not governed solely by a timing process.
实验一在三个阶段研究了强化物大小对低速率差别强化(DRL)程序表现的影响。在第一阶段,两组大鼠(n = 6和5)在DRI. 72秒程序下做出反应,强化物大小为30或300微升水。习得后,对每只大鼠的水量进行了反转。在第二阶段,研究了相同强化物大小对DRL 18秒程序表现在不同条件下的影响。在第三阶段,每只大鼠在DR1. 18秒程序下做出反应,其中水量每天在30和300微升之间交替。在实验1的每个阶段,较大的强化物大小导致更高的反应率和更低的强化率。在较大强化物大小条件下,反应间隔时间分布的峰值处于较低值。在实验2中,3只鸽子在DRL 20秒程序下做出反应,其中强化物大小(1秒或6秒获取谷物)逐次变化。在较长料斗持续时间条件下出现了更高的反应率和更低的强化率。这些结果表明,在大鼠和鸽子中,较大的强化物大小都会导致DRL程序表现效率降低,并且当强化物大小在各次实验之间保持不变或每天变化时也是如此。目前的结果与先前的研究一致,即在需要一段时间无特定反应的程序下,效率会随着强化物大小的增加而降低。这些发现也支持了DRI.程序表现并非仅由计时过程控制的观点。