Nikolić Slobodan, Micić Jelena, Savić Slobodan, Gajić Milan
Institute of Forensic Medicine, University School of Medicine, Belgrade.
Srp Arh Celok Lek. 2003 May-Jun;131(5-6):244-8. doi: 10.2298/sarh0306244n.
Each fracture of long or pelvic bones as well as large contusions of subcutaneous fat tissue cause releasing of fat globules that rapidly penetrate into circulation through the ruptured veins of the injured tissue, and reach the lung circulation [1,2]. During the first phase, fat emboli block the functional lung circulation by their mechanical effect in capillaries producing so called isolated post-traumatic lung fat embolism [3]. The surface layer of a fat embolus, which is practically in liquid state, behaves as a membrane of very high density, i.e., as it is under high pressure which obstruct the blood stream [4] that is finally stopped at the level of lung blood vessels with diameter of approximately 20 mu [5]. This pathophysiological mechanism produces cor pulmonale acutum, with poor pathological findings [8]. Nowadays, the post-mortem diagnosis of lung fat embolism is based on microscopical examination of tissue specimens, usually prepared with special histological staining (Sudan III) [9]. The grading of fat embolism according to Sevitt's criteria is generally accepted [10]. Taking of slices from apicoventral areas of the lungs has been recommended [11]. With longer outliving period, the total number of fat emboli in the lung circulation gradually decreases, due to their disintegration and resorption. It has been stated that fat globules completely disappear about 4-6 weeks after injury, and that they should not be searched for microscopically in this post-traumatic phase [11].
The aim of our work was to determine whether the age of injured, their gender, total severity of trauma, outliving period, and hypovolemic shock that develops after injuring, may induce development of more severe forms of post-traumatic lung fat embolism.
A prospective histological study was performed on the autopsy material of the Institute of Forensic Medicine in Belgrade. The analyzed sample consisted of individuals with injuries that might be a source of fat emboli (fractures of long bones, large contusions of subcutaneous fat tissue). The lung slices were systematically taken and stained with special fat staining (Sudan III). In each particular case, the grade of lung fat embolism was counted on the basis of microscopical appearance, according to Sevitt's criteria. The total severity of trauma was estimated by calculation of the Injury Severity Score (ISS) [13, 14]. In no cases from the analyzed sample, the fat embolism was mentioned as either singular or plural cause of death. The obtained results were analyzed by means of appropriates statistical methods (ANOVA, LSD-test, chi 2 test. Man-Whitney test, Fischer's test of correct probability).
The analyzed sample included 58 fatally injured individuals, 39 males and 19 females. The average age was 54.10 years (SD = 16.56), the average value of ISS was 34.69 (SD = 5.88), and the average outliving period was 3.74 days (SD = 5.88). However, all these data look differently when the analyzed sample has been stratified and analyzed according to the estimated grade of lung fat embolism. It was not showed that severity of lung fat embolism depends on sex of the injured (chi 2 = 0.842; p > 0.05). The groups with the slightest and the most severe grade of lung fat embolism are statistically significantly different in relation to age of individuals (ANOVA, p = 0.017). By means of LSD test, it has been showed that the group with the most severe grade of lung fat embolism (grade III) is statistically significantly different comparing to other two groups (with grade I and II) in relation to the age of injured (the values are p = 0.16 and p = 0.19 respectively, and the both groups are less than p = 0.05). In the group with the most severe grade of lung fat embolism, the older individuals are statistically significantly represented comparing to other two groups.
The analysis of our sample showed that the most severe grade of post-traumatic lung fat embolism (microscopical grade III according to Sevitt's criteria) was determined in older individuals, more severely injured, and with shorter outliving period. The severity of fat embolism depends neither on sex of the injured, nor on development of post-traumatic hypovolemic shock. The obtained results related to the influence of hypovolemic shock on severity of fat embolism should be accepted with a caution. Namely, sometimes there is an intention to simplify a procedure of creating of autopsy conclusion about the cause of death, so that loss of blood is not mentioned at all, in spite of fact that it could have been a concurrent cause of death, while in other cases exsanguination is designated as a sole cause of death, forgetting the possibility that fat embolism could have really been the immediate cause of death.
长骨或骨盆骨折以及皮下脂肪组织的大面积挫伤都会导致脂肪球释放,这些脂肪球会通过受伤组织破裂的静脉迅速进入血液循环,并到达肺循环[1,2]。在第一阶段,脂肪栓子通过其在毛细血管中的机械作用阻塞功能性肺循环,从而产生所谓的单纯创伤后肺脂肪栓塞[3]。脂肪栓子的表层实际上处于液态,其表现如同具有极高密度的膜,即在高压下阻碍血流[4],最终血流在直径约为20微米的肺血管水平停止[5]。这种病理生理机制会导致急性肺心病,病理表现不明显[8]。如今,肺脂肪栓塞的尸检诊断基于对组织标本的显微镜检查,通常采用特殊的组织学染色(苏丹III)[9]。根据塞维特标准对脂肪栓塞进行分级已被普遍接受[10]。有人建议从肺的尖腹区域取材切片[11]。随着存活时间延长,肺循环中脂肪栓子的总数会因解体和吸收而逐渐减少。有人指出,脂肪球在受伤后约4 - 6周会完全消失,在这个创伤后阶段不应再通过显微镜寻找它们[11]。
我们研究的目的是确定受伤者的年龄、性别、创伤的总体严重程度、存活时间以及受伤后发生的低血容量性休克是否会诱发更严重形式的创伤后肺脂肪栓塞。
对贝尔格莱德法医学研究所的尸检材料进行了一项前瞻性组织学研究。分析样本包括可能成为脂肪栓子来源的受伤个体(长骨骨折、皮下脂肪组织大面积挫伤)。系统地获取肺切片并用特殊脂肪染色(苏丹III)进行染色。在每个具体病例中,根据显微镜下表现,按照塞维特标准计算肺脂肪栓塞的分级。通过计算损伤严重程度评分(ISS)[13,14]来评估创伤的总体严重程度。在分析样本的所有病例中,脂肪栓塞均未被提及为单独或共同的死亡原因。采用适当的统计方法(方差分析、LSD检验、卡方检验、曼 - 惠特尼检验、费舍尔精确概率检验)对所得结果进行分析。
分析样本包括58名致命伤个体,其中男性39名,女性19名。平均年龄为54.10岁(标准差 = 16.56),ISS平均值为34.69(标准差 = 5.88),平均存活时间为3.74天(标准差 = 5.88)。然而,当根据估计的肺脂肪栓塞分级对分析样本进行分层和分析时,所有这些数据看起来有所不同。结果表明,肺脂肪栓塞的严重程度并不取决于受伤者的性别(卡方 = 0.842;p > 0.05)。肺脂肪栓塞程度最轻和最重的组在个体年龄方面存在统计学显著差异(方差分析,p = 0.017)。通过LSD检验表明,肺脂肪栓塞程度最重的组(III级)与其他两组(I级和II级)在受伤者年龄方面存在统计学显著差异(p值分别为0.16和0.19,两组均小于p = 0.05)。在肺脂肪栓塞程度最重的组中,年龄较大的个体在统计学上显著多于其他两组。
对我们样本的分析表明,创伤后肺脂肪栓塞最严重的级别(根据塞维特标准为显微镜下III级)在年龄较大、受伤更严重且存活时间较短的个体中被确定。脂肪栓塞的严重程度既不取决于受伤者的性别,也不取决于创伤后低血容量性休克的发生。关于低血容量性休克对脂肪栓塞严重程度影响的所得结果应谨慎接受。也就是说,有时为了简化关于死亡原因的尸检结论程序,完全不提失血情况,尽管失血可能是并发的死亡原因,而在其他情况下将失血指定为唯一的死亡原因,却忽略了脂肪栓塞可能才是真正直接死亡原因的可能性。