儿童疾病负担相关政策信息的差距:一项系统综述
Gaps in policy-relevant information on burden of disease in children: a systematic review.
作者信息
Rudan Igor, Lawn Joy, Cousens Simon, Rowe Alexander K, Boschi-Pinto Cynthia, Tomasković Lana, Mendoza Walter, Lanata Claudio F, Roca-Feltrer Arantxa, Carneiro Ilona, Schellenberg Joanna A, Polasek Ozren, Weber Martin, Bryce Jennifer, Morris Saul S, Black Robert E, Campbell Harry
机构信息
Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Edinburgh Medical School, Edinburgh, UK.
出版信息
Lancet. 2005;365(9476):2031-40. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(05)66697-4.
BACKGROUND
Valid information about cause-specific child mortality and morbidity is an essential foundation for national and international health policy. We undertook a systematic review to investigate the geographical dispersion of and time trends in publication for policy-relevant information about children's health and to assess associations between the availability of reliable data and poverty.
METHODS
We identified data available on Jan 1, 2001, and published since 1980, for the major causes of morbidity and mortality in young children. Studies with relevant data were assessed against a set of inclusion criteria to identify those likely to provide unbiased estimates of the burden of childhood disease in the community.
FINDINGS
Only 308 information units from more than 17,000 papers identified were regarded as possible unbiased sources for estimates of childhood disease burden. The geographical distribution of these information units revealed a pattern of small well-researched populations surrounded by large areas with little available information. No reliable population-based data were identified from many of the world's poorest countries, which account for about a third of all deaths of children worldwide. The number of new studies diminished over the last 10 years investigated.
INTERPRETATION
The number of population-based studies yielding estimates of burden of childhood disease from less developed countries was low. The decreasing trend over time suggests reductions in research investment in this sphere. Data are especially sparse from the world's least developed countries with the highest child mortality. Guidelines are needed for the conduct of burden-of-disease studies together with an international research policy that gives increased emphasis to global equity and coverage so that knowledge can be generated from all regions of the world.
背景
关于特定病因的儿童死亡率和发病率的有效信息是国家和国际卫生政策的重要基础。我们进行了一项系统综述,以调查与儿童健康相关的政策信息的地理分布和发表时间趋势,并评估可靠数据的可得性与贫困之间的关联。
方法
我们确定了2001年1月1日可获取且自1980年以来发表的有关幼儿发病和死亡主要原因的数据。对具有相关数据的研究依据一套纳入标准进行评估,以确定那些可能提供社区儿童疾病负担无偏估计的研究。
结果
在识别出的17000多篇论文中,仅有308个信息单元被视为可能是儿童疾病负担估计的无偏来源。这些信息单元的地理分布显示出一种模式,即少量研究充分的人群被大片信息匮乏的区域所包围。世界上许多最贫困国家没有识别出可靠的基于人群的数据,而这些国家的儿童死亡数约占全球儿童死亡总数的三分之一。在过去10年的研究中,新研究的数量有所减少。
解读
来自欠发达国家的、能够得出儿童疾病负担估计值的基于人群的研究数量较少。随着时间推移的下降趋势表明该领域研究投入的减少。儿童死亡率最高的世界最不发达国家的数据尤其匮乏。需要制定疾病负担研究指南以及一项更加强调全球公平和覆盖范围的国际研究政策,以便能够从世界所有地区获取知识。