在目标覆盖范围内,印度艾滋病防治倡议对女性性工作者的干预措施可取得怎样的成效?来自印度南部的模型预测。
What is the achievable effectiveness of the India AIDS Initiative intervention among female sex workers under target coverage? Model projections from southern India.
作者信息
Williams J R, Foss A M, Vickerman P, Watts C, Ramesh B M, Reza-Paul S, Washington R G, Moses S, Blanchard J, Lowndes C M, Alary M, Boily M-C
机构信息
Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, Imperial College London, St Mary's Hospital, Norfolk Place, London W2 1PG, UK.
出版信息
Sex Transm Infect. 2006 Oct;82(5):372-80. doi: 10.1136/sti.2006.020875.
BACKGROUND
The India AIDS Initiative (Avahan) prevention programme funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation aims to reduce HIV prevalence in high risk groups such as female and male sex workers and their clients, to limit HIV transmission in the general population.
OBJECTIVES
To assess the potential effectiveness of the Avahan intervention at the level of coverage targeted, in different epidemiological settings in India.
METHODS
A deterministic compartmental model of the transmission dynamics of HIV and two sexually transmitted infections, and sensitivity analysis techniques, were used, in combination with available behavioural and epidemiological data from Mysore and Bagalkot districts in the Indian state of Karnataka, to evaluate the syndromic sexually transmitted infection (STI) management (STI treatment), periodic presumptive treatment of STI (PPT), and condom components of the Avahan intervention targeted to female sex workers (FSW).
RESULTS
If all components of the intervention reach target coverage (that is, PPT, STI treatment and condom use), the intervention is expected to prevent 22-35% of all new HIV infections in FSW and in the total population over 5 years in a low transmission setting like Mysore, and to be half as effective in high transmission settings such as Bagalkot. The results were sensitive to small variations in intervention coverage. The condom component alone is expected to prevent around 20% of all new HIV infections over 5 years in Mysore and around 6% for the STI component alone; compared with 7%-14% for the PPT component alone. Multivariate sensitivity analyses suggested that interventions may be more effective in settings with low FSW HIV prevalence and small FSW populations, whereas HIV prevalence was most influenced by sexual behaviour and condom use parameters for FSW.
CONCLUSION
The Avahan intervention is expected to be effective. However, to be able to demonstrate effectiveness empirically in the different settings, it is important to achieve target coverage or higher, which in the case of PPT could take a number of years to achieve. These preliminary model predictions need to be validated with more detailed mathematical models, as better data on sexual behaviour, condom use, STI and HIV trends over time, and intervention coverage data accumulate over the course of the programme.
背景
由比尔及梅琳达·盖茨基金会资助的印度艾滋病防治计划(阿瓦汉)旨在降低女性和男性性工作者及其客户等高危人群中的艾滋病毒流行率,以限制艾滋病毒在普通人群中的传播。
目的
评估阿瓦汉干预措施在印度不同流行病学环境中针对目标覆盖水平的潜在效果。
方法
采用艾滋病毒和两种性传播感染传播动力学的确定性分区模型以及敏感性分析技术,并结合印度卡纳塔克邦迈索尔和巴加尔科特地区现有的行为和流行病学数据,评估针对女性性工作者的阿瓦汉干预措施的症状性性传播感染(STI)管理(STI治疗)、STI定期推定治疗(PPT)和避孕套组成部分。
结果
如果干预措施的所有组成部分都达到目标覆盖水平(即PPT、STI治疗和避孕套使用),预计该干预措施在迈索尔这样的低传播环境中,5年内可预防女性性工作者及总人口中22%-35%的所有新增艾滋病毒感染,而在巴加尔科特这样的高传播环境中的效果仅为前者的一半。结果对干预覆盖范围的微小变化很敏感。仅避孕套组成部分预计在迈索尔5年内可预防约20%的所有新增艾滋病毒感染,仅STI组成部分约为6%;相比之下,仅PPT组成部分为7%-14%。多变量敏感性分析表明,干预措施在女性性工作者艾滋病毒流行率低且女性性工作者群体小的环境中可能更有效,而艾滋病毒流行率受女性性工作者性行为和避孕套使用参数的影响最大。
结论
预计阿瓦汉干预措施会有效。然而,要在不同环境中通过实证证明有效性,实现目标覆盖水平或更高水平很重要,就PPT而言,这可能需要数年时间才能实现。随着性行为、避孕套使用、STI和艾滋病毒随时间变化的趋势以及干预覆盖范围数据在该计划过程中不断积累,这些初步模型预测需要用更详细的数学模型进行验证。