Newcombe Nora S, Chiang Noelle Chiau-Ru
Department of Psychology, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19122, USA.
Mem Cognit. 2007 Jul;35(5):895-909. doi: 10.3758/bf03193464.
People show biases or distortions in their geographical judgments, such as mistakenly judging Rome to be south of Chicago (the Chicago-Rome illusion). These errors may derive from either perceptual heuristics or categorical organization. However, previous work on geographic knowledge has generally examined people's judgments of real-world locations for which learning history is unknown. This article reports experiments on the learning of hypothetical geographical spaces, in which participants acquired information in a fashion designed to control real-world factors, such as variable travel experiences or stereotypes about other countries, as well as to mimic initial encounters with locations through reading or conventional school-based geography education. Five experiments combine to suggest that biases in judgment based on learning of this kind are different in key regards from those seen with real-world geography and may be based more on the use of perceptual heuristics than on categorical organization.
人们在地理判断中表现出偏差或扭曲,比如错误地判断罗马在芝加哥以南(芝加哥-罗马错觉)。这些错误可能源于感知启发法或类别组织。然而,先前关于地理知识的研究通常考察的是人们对现实世界地点的判断,而这些地点的学习历史是未知的。本文报告了关于假设地理空间学习的实验,在这些实验中,参与者以一种旨在控制现实世界因素的方式获取信息,这些因素包括不同的旅行经历或对其他国家的刻板印象,同时也模仿通过阅读或传统的学校地理教育首次接触地点的情况。五项实验综合表明,基于此类学习的判断偏差在关键方面与现实世界地理中的偏差不同,并且可能更多地基于感知启发法的运用而非类别组织。