不同 EEG 静息态网络参考的比较研究:无穷参考的使用。
A comparative study of different references for EEG default mode network: the use of the infinity reference.
机构信息
School of Life Science and Technology, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, Chengdu 610054, China.
出版信息
Clin Neurophysiol. 2010 Dec;121(12):1981-91. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2010.03.056. Epub 2010 Jun 12.
OBJECTIVE
The choice of electroencephalograph (EEG) reference is a critical issue for the study of brain activity. The present study addressed the use of the infinity reference obtained by the reference electrode standardisation technique (REST) in the study of EEG default mode network (DMN).
METHODS
A total of 100 randomly positioned source configurations, each consisting of two dipoles with coherent waveforms, were adopted for simulating EEG networks. Dense (129-channel), eyes-closed EEG was recorded from 15 subjects. Simulated data with infinity as reference and the real data were re-referenced to reconstructed infinity (REST), their average (AR), linked mastoids (LM) and left mastoid (L) references. For simulated data, the effects of different references on coherence and network were investigated. For real data, spectral properties of seven conventional EEG frequency bands were first analysed and then DMN was constructed based on the coherence.
RESULTS
The simulation showed that REST can exactly recover the true EEG network configuration. For real EEG data, significant differences among references were found for the power spectra, coherence and DMN configuration. Compared with REST, the long-distance connectivity between anterior and posterior areas was strengthened by AR, and the connectivity over posterior areas was destroyed when LM and L were employed. Moreover, all comparisons demonstrated frequency-dependent reference effects.
CONCLUSIONS
Non-neutral reference influences the power spectra, coherence as well as the network analysis. REST demonstrates its validity in data referencing, and meanwhile, AR is much closer to REST than the other references in terms of spectra and coherence. However, the DMN alters a great deal with AR.
SIGNIFICANCE
The results underscore the importance of considering EEG reference effects in the functional connectivity studies. REST is a promising reference technique for objective comparison in cross-laboratory studies and clinical practices.
目的
脑电图(EEG)参考的选择是研究大脑活动的一个关键问题。本研究探讨了参考电极标准化技术(REST)获得的无穷大参考在默认模式网络(DMN)的 EEG 研究中的应用。
方法
采用总共 100 个随机定位的源配置,每个配置由两个具有相干波形的偶极子组成,用于模拟 EEG 网络。从 15 名受试者记录密集(129 通道)、闭眼 EEG。模拟数据以无穷大作为参考,真实数据以重建的无穷大(REST)、平均(AR)、链接乳突(LM)和左乳突(L)参考重新参考。对于模拟数据,研究了不同参考对相干性和网络的影响。对于真实数据,首先分析了七个常规 EEG 频带的光谱特性,然后基于相干性构建 DMN。
结果
模拟表明 REST 可以准确恢复真实 EEG 网络结构。对于真实 EEG 数据,发现参考之间的频谱、相干性和 DMN 配置存在显著差异。与 REST 相比,AR 增强了前后区域之间的远距离连接,而 LM 和 L 则破坏了后区域之间的连接。此外,所有比较都表明了参考的频率依赖性效应。
结论
非中性参考会影响频谱、相干性以及网络分析。REST 在数据参考方面表现出有效性,同时,在频谱和相干性方面,AR 比其他参考更接近 REST。然而,AR 会使 DMN 发生很大变化。
意义
结果强调了在功能连接研究中考虑 EEG 参考效应的重要性。REST 是一种有前途的参考技术,可用于跨实验室研究和临床实践中的客观比较。