Balota D A, Cowan N, Engle R W
Department of Psychology, Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri 63130.
J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn. 1990 May;16(3):446-56. doi: 10.1037//0278-7393.16.3.446.
Four experiments are presented that address the stimulus suffix effect for linguistically coherent spoken materials. In Experiment 1, definitions of low-frequency words were presented for online written recall. Each definition was followed by a nonword speech suffix presented in the same voice as the definition, the same nonword presented in a different voice, or a tone. The results yielded a significant reduction in the recall of the terminal words of the definitions in the speech suffix conditions compared with the tone control. This general pattern was replicated in Experiment 2, in which subjects did not begin their recall until the suffix item or tone was presented, although the magnitude of the suffix effect was reduced in this experiment. In Experiment 3, sentences that were part of a cohesive story were presented for on-line recall. Here, the suffix effect was considerably reduced compared with the suffix effect found with the definitions presented in Experiments 1 and 2. This pattern was replicated in Experiment 4, in which subjects did not begin their recall of the story sentences until the speech suffix or tone was presented. Overall, the results suggest that auditory memory interference can take place for linguistically coherent speech, although the magnitude of the interference decreases as one increases the level of linguistic structure in the to-be-recalled materials. Implications of the present results for current models of natural language processing are discussed.
本文介绍了四项实验,这些实验探讨了语言连贯的口语材料的刺激后缀效应。在实验1中,呈现低频单词的定义以供在线书面回忆。每个定义之后都会呈现一个非词语音后缀,该后缀的发音与定义相同、呈现相同的非词但发音不同,或者呈现一个音调。结果显示,与音调控制条件相比,语音后缀条件下定义的结尾单词的回忆率显著降低。这一总体模式在实验2中得到了重复,在该实验中,受试者直到后缀项或音调出现才开始回忆,尽管该实验中后缀效应的程度有所降低。在实验3中,呈现了一个连贯故事中的句子以供在线回忆。在这里,与实验1和实验2中呈现定义时发现的后缀效应相比,后缀效应显著降低。这一模式在实验4中得到了重复,在该实验中,受试者直到语音后缀或音调出现才开始回忆故事句子。总体而言,结果表明,对于语言连贯的言语,听觉记忆干扰可能会发生,尽管随着待回忆材料中语言结构水平的提高,干扰程度会降低。本文讨论了当前结果对当前自然语言处理模型的影响。