学术医学领域中代表性不足的少数族裔教员:对少数族裔教员发展的系统评价
Underrepresented minority faculty in academic medicine: a systematic review of URM faculty development.
作者信息
Rodriguez José E, Campbell Kendall M, Fogarty John P, Williams Roxann L
机构信息
Department of Family Medicine and Rural Health, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL.
出版信息
Fam Med. 2014 Feb;46(2):100-4.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES
Retention and recruitment of minority faculty members continues to be a concern of medical schools because there is higher attrition and talent loss among this group. While much has been written, there has not been a systematic review published on this topic. This is the first study to use evidence-based medicine (EBM) criteria and apply it to this issue.
METHODS
We searched MEDLINE, Web of Knowledge, ProQuest, and Google Scholar for papers relating to the recruitment and retention of minority faculty. We then graded the evidence using the EBM criteria as defined by the American Academy of Family Physicians. The same criteria were applied to extract evidence-based observations of problems in recruitment and retention for minority faculty.
RESULTS
Of the 548 studies identified and reviewed, 11 met inclusion criteria for this literature review. This article presents the data from the reviewed papers that described or evaluated minority faculty development programs. Faculty development programs in 15 different institutions showed mentoring and faculty development for minority faculty could increase retention, academic productivity, and promotion rates for this group.
CONCLUSIONS
For medical schools to be successful in retention and recruitment of minority medical school faculty, specific programs need to be in place. Overall evidence is strong that faculty development programs and mentoring programs increase retention, productivity, and promotion for this group of medical faculty. This paper is a call to action for more faculty development and mentorship programs to reduce the disparities that exist between minority faculty and all other faculty members.
背景与目的
少数族裔教员的留任和招聘仍是医学院校关注的问题,因为该群体的人员流失率和人才损失更高。尽管已有大量相关著述,但尚未有关于这一主题的系统综述发表。这是第一项运用循证医学(EBM)标准并将其应用于该问题的研究。
方法
我们在医学文献数据库(MEDLINE)、科学网(Web of Knowledge)、ProQuest和谷歌学术中搜索与少数族裔教员招聘和留任相关的论文。然后,我们根据美国家庭医师学会定义的EBM标准对证据进行分级。运用相同标准提取关于少数族裔教员招聘和留任问题的循证观察结果。
结果
在检索和审阅的548项研究中,有11项符合本文献综述的纳入标准。本文呈现了经审阅论文中描述或评估少数族裔教员发展项目的数据。15个不同机构的教员发展项目表明,针对少数族裔教员的指导和教员发展可提高该群体的留任率、学术产出率和晋升率。
结论
医学院校若要成功留任和招聘少数族裔医学院教员,需要制定具体项目。总体证据有力表明,教员发展项目和指导项目可提高这一医学教员群体的留任率、产出率和晋升率。本文呼吁开展更多教员发展和指导项目,以缩小少数族裔教员与所有其他教员之间存在的差距。