Community and Conservation Ecology, Centre for Ecological and Evolutionary Studies, University of Groningen, Nijenborgh 7, 9747AG, Groningen, The Netherlands,
Oecologia. 2014 Jun;175(2):639-49. doi: 10.1007/s00442-014-2920-z. Epub 2014 Apr 5.
African savannahs are among the few places on earth where diverse communities of mega- and meso-sized ungulate grazers dominate ecosystem functioning. Less conspicuous, but even more diverse, are the communities of herbivorous insects such as grasshoppers, which share the same food. Various studies investigated the community assembly of these groups separately, but it is poorly known how ungulate communities shape grasshopper communities. Here, we investigated how ungulate species of different body size alter grasshopper communities in a South African savannah. White rhino is the most abundant vertebrate herbivore in our study site. Other common mesoherbivores include buffalo, zebra and impala. We hypothesized that white rhinos would have greater impact than mesoherbivores on grasshopper communities. Using 10-year-old exclosures, at eight sites we compared the effects of ungulates on grasshopper communities in three nested treatments: (i) unfenced plots ('control plots') with all vertebrate herbivores present, (ii) plots with a low cable fence, excluding white rhino ('megaherbivore exclosures'), and (iii) plots with tall fences, excluding all herbivores larger than rodents ('complete ungulate exclosures'). In each plot, we collected data of vegetation structure, grass and grasshopper community composition. Complete ungulate exclosures contained 30% taller vegetation than megaherbivore exclosures and they were dominated by different grass and grasshopper species. Grasshoppers in complete ungulate exclosures were on average 3.5 mm longer than grasshoppers in megaherbivore exclosures, possibly due to changes in plant communities or vegetation structure. We conclude that surprisingly, in this megaherbivore hotspot, mesoherbivores, instead of megaherbivores, most strongly affect grasshopper communities.
非洲稀树草原是地球上少数几个多样化的大型和中型有蹄类食草动物群落主导生态系统功能的地方之一。不太引人注意的是,同样以草为食的食草昆虫(如蝗虫)群落更加多样化。各种研究分别调查了这些群体的群落组装,但人们对有蹄类动物群落如何塑造蝗虫群落知之甚少。在这里,我们调查了不同体型的有蹄类动物如何改变南非稀树草原上的蝗虫群落。白犀牛是我们研究地点中最丰富的脊椎动物食草动物。其他常见的中型食草动物包括水牛、斑马和黑斑羚。我们假设白犀牛对蝗虫群落的影响将大于中型食草动物。使用 10 年历史的围栏,我们在八个地点比较了有蹄类动物对三个嵌套处理中的蝗虫群落的影响:(i)无围栏的斑块(“对照斑块”),有所有脊椎动物食草动物;(ii)有低电缆围栏的斑块,排除白犀牛(“大型食草动物围栏”);(iii)有高围栏的斑块,排除所有大于啮齿动物的食草动物(“完全有蹄类动物围栏”)。在每个斑块中,我们收集了植被结构、草和蝗虫群落组成的数据。完全有蹄类动物围栏的植被比大型食草动物围栏高 30%,它们主要由不同的草和蝗虫物种组成。完全有蹄类动物围栏中的蝗虫平均比大型食草动物围栏中的蝗虫长 3.5 毫米,这可能是由于植物群落或植被结构的变化。我们的结论是,令人惊讶的是,在这个大型食草动物热点地区,中型食草动物而不是大型食草动物,对蝗虫群落的影响最大。