初级保健提供者和患者对肺癌筛查的看法。定性研究。
Primary Care Provider and Patient Perspectives on Lung Cancer Screening. A Qualitative Study.
机构信息
1 Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care and Sleep Medicine, Department of Medicine.
3 College of Nursing, and.
出版信息
Ann Am Thorac Soc. 2016 Nov;13(11):1977-1982. doi: 10.1513/AnnalsATS.201604-286OC.
RATIONALE
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends annual low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) for lung cancer screening in high-risk individuals. Preventive healthcare is provided predominantly by primary care providers (PCPs). Successful implementation of a screening program requires acceptance and participation by both providers and patients, with available collaboration with pulmonologists.
OBJECTIVES
To identify perceptions of and perspectives on lung cancer screening and implementation among PCPs and eligible veteran patients at high risk for lung cancer.
METHODS
We conducted a qualitative study using grounded theory in which 28 veterans and 13 PCPs completed a questionnaire and participated in focus groups. Sessions were recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed with NVivo 10 software. Counts and percentages were used to report questionnaire results.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS
While 58% percent of providers were aware of lung cancer screening guidelines, many could not recall the exact patient eligibility criteria. Most patients were willing to undergo LDCT screening and identified smoking as a risk factor for lung cancer, but they did not recall their PCP explaining the reason for the testing. All providers assessed smoking behavior, but only 23% referred active smokers for formal cessation services. Patients volunteered information regarding their hurdles with smoking cessation while discussing risk factors for cancer. PCPs cited time constraints as a reason for lack of appropriate counseling and shared decision making. Both parties were willing to explore modalities and decision aid tools to improve shared decision making; however, while patients were interested in individual risk prediction, few PCPs believed statistical approaches to counseling would confuse patients.
CONCLUSIONS
While patients and providers are receptive to LDCT screening, efforts are needed to improve guideline knowledge and adherence among providers. System-level interventions are necessary to facilitate time and resources for shared decision making and smoking cessation counseling and treatment. Further research is needed to identify optimal strategies for effective lung cancer screening in the community.
背景
美国预防服务工作组建议对高危人群进行年度低剂量计算机断层扫描(LDCT)肺癌筛查。初级保健提供者(PCP)主要提供预防性保健服务。成功实施筛查计划需要提供者和患者的接受和参与,同时与肺病专家进行合作。
目的
确定 PCP 和符合条件的高危肺癌退伍军人患者对肺癌筛查和实施的看法和观点。
方法
我们使用扎根理论进行了一项定性研究,28 名退伍军人和 13 名 PCP 完成了一份问卷,并参加了焦点小组。对会议进行了录音、逐字记录,并使用 NVivo 10 软件进行了分析。使用计数和百分比报告问卷结果。
测量和主要结果
虽然 58%的提供者了解肺癌筛查指南,但许多人无法回忆起确切的患者资格标准。大多数患者愿意接受 LDCT 筛查,并将吸烟视为肺癌的一个危险因素,但他们不记得他们的 PCP 解释过测试的原因。所有的提供者都评估了吸烟行为,但只有 23%的人将吸烟者转诊接受正式的戒烟服务。患者在讨论癌症风险因素时自愿提供有关他们戒烟障碍的信息。PCP 指出时间限制是缺乏适当咨询和共同决策的原因。双方都愿意探索改善共同决策的方式和决策辅助工具;然而,尽管患者对个体风险预测感兴趣,但很少有 PCP 认为统计方法的咨询会使患者感到困惑。
结论
虽然患者和提供者对 LDCT 筛查持接受态度,但仍需努力提高提供者对指南的了解和遵守。需要系统层面的干预措施,为共同决策和戒烟咨询以及治疗提供时间和资源。需要进一步研究以确定在社区中进行有效肺癌筛查的最佳策略。