Intravascular hemolysis results in the release of cell-free hemoglobin and heme in plasma. In sickle cell disease, the fragility of the sickle red blood cell leads to chronic hemolysis, which can contribute to oxidative damage and activation of inflammatory pathways. The scavenger proteins haptoglobin and hemopexin provide pathways to remove hemoglobin and heme, respectively, from the circulation. Heme also intercalates in membranes of blood cells and endothelial cells in the vasculature and associates with other plasma components such as albumin and lipoproteins. Hemopexin has a much higher affinity and can strip heme from the other pools and detoxify plasma from cell-free circulatory heme. However, due to chronic hemolysis, hemopexin is depleted in individuals with sickle cell disease. Thus, cell-free unbound heme is expected to accumulate in plasma. We developed a methodology for the accurate quantification of the fraction of heme, which is pathologically relevant in sickle cell disease, that does not appear to be sequestered to a plasma compartment. Our data show significant variation in the concentration of unbound heme, and rather unexpectedly, the size of the unbound fraction does not correlate to the degree of hemolysis, as measured by the concentration of bound heme. Very high heme concentrations (>150 µM) were obtained in some plasma with unbound concentrations that were several fold lower than in plasma with much lower hemolysis (<50 µM). These findings underscore the long-term effects of chronic hemolysis on the blood components and of the disruption of the essential equilibrium between release of hemoproteins/heme in the circulation and adaptative response of the scavenging/removal mechanisms. Understanding the clinical implications of this loss of response may provide insights into diagnostic and therapeutic targets in patients with sickle cell disease.