与局部外用米诺地尔联合口服非那雄胺相比,局部外用米诺地尔联合口服螺内酯治疗女性雄激素性脱发、女性和男性脱发模式的疗效:一项双盲随机临床试验。
The efficacy of the combination of topical minoxidil and oral spironolactone compared with the combination of topical minoxidil and oral finasteride in women with androgenic alopecia, female and male hair loss patterns: A blinded randomized clinical trial.
作者信息
Sadeghzadeh Bazargan Afsaneh, Tavana Zeynab, Dehghani Abbas, Jafarzadeh Alireza, Tabavar Anahita, Alavi Rad Ehsan, Goodarzi Azadeh
机构信息
Department of Dermatology, Rasool Akram Medical Complex Clinical Research Development Center (RCRDC), School of Medicine, Iran University of Medical Sciences (IUMS), Tehran, Iran.
Department of Radiology, School of Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS), Tehran, Iran.
出版信息
J Cosmet Dermatol. 2024 Feb;23(2):543-551. doi: 10.1111/jocd.15979. Epub 2023 Aug 31.
INTRODUCTION
Androgenic alopecia (AGA) is the most common cause of hair loss in women, affecting their quality of life. The present study was conducted with the aim of comparing the combined effect of topical minoxidil and oral spironolactone with the combined effect of topical minoxidil and oral finasteride in women with AGA, female and male hair loss patterns.
METHOD
This clinical study was performed on 60 women suffering from AGA. The patients were divided into two groups receiving spironolactone 100 mg/day and finasteride 5 mg/day. In addition, a 2% minoxidil solution was used in all patients in addition to treatment with finasteride or spironolactone. At 2 months after initiation and at the end of treatment, patients were evaluated using the Ludwig/Norwood-Hamilton scale and the degree of physician and patient satisfaction.
RESULTS
After 2 months, hair density, hair thickness, and hair loss had improved in both groups; however, statistically, there was no significant difference between the two groups with respect to these parameters (p > 0.05). After 4 months, a significant difference was found between the two groups in terms of treatment response (physician satisfaction), hair density, and hair loss severity. So that, the drugs used were ineffective in 6.7% of cases in the minoxidil-spironolactone group and in 16.7% of cases in the minoxidil-finasteride group. In addition, 43.3% of cases in the minoxidil-spironolactone group and 53% in the minoxidil-finasteride group responded well to treatment. The treatment effect was excellent in 56.7% and 0% of the mentioned groups, respectively, and the mentioned difference was statistically significant (p: 0.01). The response to treatment in female pattern hair loss (FPHL) was not statistically significant (p: 0.52), but there was a significant difference in the response to both treatments in male pattern hair loss (MPHL; p: 0.007). In terms of patient satisfaction, minoxidil-spironolactone treatment was significantly better than minoxidil-finasteride regarding hair density and severity of hair loss (p: 0.01). Finally, in terms of treatment complications, the patients in two groups did not have any serious adverse effects.
CONCLUSION
The combination of minoxidil and spironolactone could be considered a more effective treatment than the combination of minoxidil and finasteride in women with AGA, FPHL, and MPHL.
引言
雄激素性脱发(AGA)是女性脱发最常见的原因,影响她们的生活质量。本研究旨在比较局部外用米诺地尔和口服螺内酯联合用药与局部外用米诺地尔和口服非那雄胺联合用药对患有AGA、女性和男性脱发模式的女性的综合效果。
方法
本临床研究对60名患有AGA的女性进行。患者被分为两组,分别接受100毫克/天的螺内酯和5毫克/天的非那雄胺。此外,除了使用非那雄胺或螺内酯治疗外,所有患者均使用2%的米诺地尔溶液。在开始治疗2个月后和治疗结束时,使用路德维希/诺伍德 - 汉密尔顿量表以及医生和患者的满意度对患者进行评估。
结果
2个月后,两组的头发密度、头发厚度和脱发情况均有所改善;然而,在统计学上,两组在这些参数方面没有显著差异(p>0.05)。4个月后,两组在治疗反应(医生满意度)、头发密度和脱发严重程度方面存在显著差异。米诺地尔 - 螺内酯组6.7%的病例和米诺地尔 - 非那雄胺组16.7%的病例中所用药物无效。此外,米诺地尔 - 螺内酯组43.3%的病例和米诺地尔 - 非那雄胺组53%的病例对治疗反应良好。上述两组的治疗效果分别为56.7%和0%极佳,且上述差异具有统计学意义(p:0.01)。女性型脱发(FPHL)对治疗的反应无统计学意义(p:0.52),但男性型脱发(MPHL)对两种治疗的反应存在显著差异(p:0.007)。在患者满意度方面,米诺地尔 - 螺内酯治疗在头发密度和脱发严重程度方面明显优于米诺地尔 - 非那雄胺(p:0.01)。最后,在治疗并发症方面,两组患者均未出现任何严重不良反应。
结论
对于患有AGA、FPHL和MPHL的女性,米诺地尔和螺内酯联合用药可能比米诺地尔和非那雄胺联合用药更有效。