用于测量受呼吸道疾病影响的幼儿(0-5 岁)健康相关生活质量的项目库 - 来自南非西开普省的专家利益相关者和最终用户。
An item bank to measure health-related quality of life among young children (0-5-years-old) affected by respiratory illnesses - expert stakeholders and end-users from the Western Cape, South Africa.
机构信息
Desmond Tutu TB Centre, Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Stellenbosch University, Cape Town, South Africa.
School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health, The University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
出版信息
Health Qual Life Outcomes. 2024 Oct 29;22(1):95. doi: 10.1186/s12955-024-02308-0.
BACKGROUND
Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is a crucial patient-centred outcome for developing policy. However, there is a lack of appropriate HRQoL measures for young children (0-5-years), who are particularly vulnerable to respiratory illnesses like pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) and other respiratory infections, especially in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). We aimed to develop a disease-specific HRQoL item bank for young children with acute and chronic respiratory illnesses.
METHODS
An exploratory sequential design with three phases was used to develop a HRQoL item bank. The content validity of the item bank was evaluated by local and international experts specialising in HRQoL and child health. The group included paediatric pulmonologists, researchers with expertise in respiratory illnesses, and experts in scale development. Cognitive interviews with 37 caregivers of children with TB, pneumonia, adenovirus respiratory infection, other lower respiratory tract infections, reactive airway disease, and protracted bronchitis in Cape Town, South Africa, and consultations with 22 stakeholders were conducted for final revisions. The item bank was progressively refined at each phase of the study.
FINDINGS
The Delphi experts recommended dividing the item bank into two age groups (0-2-years and 3-5-years) and using a 5-point Likert scale. Overall, 41 items (42%) met the predetermined > 70% threshold for inclusion in the item bank. Cognitive interviews confirmed that the domains were relevant. Minor modifications were made to five items in cohort 1 (0-2-years) and seven in cohort 2 (3-5-years), with 8 items (13%) and 14 items (22%) excluded. Phase 3 consultations emphasised the importance of including all seven domains and expanding the items to cover early childhood development, play, social interactions, and care routines. The final item bank includes versions for both age groups and incorporates these refinements.
CONCLUSION
An item bank was developed as a first step to develop a comprehensive disease-specific HRQoL tool for young children with respiratory illnesses in an LMIC. Input from caregivers and content experts was crucial in creating two HRQoL item banks tailored to the developmental differences between 0 and 2 and 3-5-year age groups. Their contributions ensured the tool effectively captures age-appropriate aspects of HRQoL. Future studies should focus on assessing the validity and reliability of these item banks.
背景
健康相关生活质量(HRQoL)是制定政策的关键患者为中心的结果。然而,对于 0-5 岁的幼儿,缺乏适当的 HRQoL 衡量标准,幼儿特别容易患肺结核(PTB)和其他呼吸道感染等呼吸道疾病,尤其是在中低收入国家(LMICs)。我们旨在为患有急性和慢性呼吸道疾病的幼儿开发一种特定疾病的 HRQoL 项目库。
方法
采用探索性序贯设计,分三个阶段开发 HRQoL 项目库。项目库的内容有效性由专门从事 HRQoL 和儿童健康的本地和国际专家进行评估。专家组包括儿科肺科医生、呼吸道疾病专家和量表开发专家。在南非开普敦对 37 名结核病、肺炎、腺病毒呼吸道感染、其他下呼吸道感染、反应性气道疾病和迁延性支气管炎患儿的照顾者进行了认知访谈,并与 22 名利益相关者进行了咨询,以进行最终修订。项目库在研究的每个阶段都在逐步完善。
结果
德尔菲专家建议将项目库分为两个年龄组(0-2 岁和 3-5 岁)并使用 5 分李克特量表。总体而言,有 41 项(42%)符合纳入项目库的预定>70%阈值。认知访谈证实了这些领域的相关性。在队列 1(0-2 岁)中对 5 项进行了细微修改,在队列 2(3-5 岁)中对 7 项进行了修改,排除了 8 项(13%)和 14 项(22%)。第三阶段的磋商强调了纳入所有七个领域以及扩展涵盖幼儿发育、游戏、社交互动和护理常规的项目的重要性。最终的项目库包括两个年龄组的版本,并包含这些改进。
结论
作为开发针对中低收入国家幼儿呼吸道疾病的全面特定疾病 HRQoL 工具的第一步,开发了一个项目库。照顾者和内容专家的投入对于创建针对 0-2 岁和 3-5 岁年龄组发育差异的两个 HRQoL 项目库至关重要。他们的贡献确保了该工具能够有效捕捉到适合年龄的 HRQoL 方面。未来的研究应侧重于评估这些项目库的有效性和可靠性。