Alnot J Y
Département de Chirurgie de la Main et du Membre Supérieur, Hôpital Bichat, Paris, France.
Acta Orthop Belg. 1999 Mar;65(1):10-22.
A critical review is presented of the indications for nerve repair or transfer and for palliative operations in the management of paralytic shoulder following traumatic neurological injuries in the adult. Different situations are considered: paralytic shoulder following supraclavicular lesions of the brachial plexus, following retro- and infraclavicular lesions and following lesions to the terminal branches of the plexus (axillary, suprascapular and musculocutaneous nerves) and finally problems related to lesions of the accessory nerve and the long thoracic nerve. I. Supraclavicular lesions of the brachial plexus. In complete (C5 to T1) lesions, the possibilities for nerve repair or transfer are at best limited, and the aim is to restore active flexion of the elbow. Palliative operations may be associated in order to stabilize the shoulder. In case of a complete C5 to T1 root avulsion, amputation at the distal humerus may be considered but is rarely performed combined with shoulder arthrodesis if the trapezius and serratus anterior muscles are functioning. The shoulder may also be stabilized by a ligament plasty using the coracoacromial ligament. In cases where the supraspinatus and long head of the biceps have recovered, but where active external rotation is absent, function may be improved by derotation osteotomy of the humerus. In partial C5,6 or C5,6,7 lesions, the indications for nerve repair and transfer are wider, as well as the indications for muscle transfers. In C5,6 lesions, a neurotization from the accessory nerve to the suprascapular nerve gives 60% satisfactory results; this is also true following treatment of C5,6,7 lesions, whereas restoration of active elbow flexion is obtained in 100% of cases in C5,6 lesions but only in 86% in C5,6,7 lesions. In cases where shoulder function has not been restored, palliative operations may be considered: arthrodesis or, more often, derotation osteotomy of the humerus which can be combined with transfer of the teres major and latissimus dorsi. II. Retro- and infraclavicular lesions of the brachial plexus. Twenty-five percent of the lesions of the brachial plexus occur in the retro- or infraclavicular region and involve the secondary trunks, most commonly the posterior trunk. Nerve repair should be performed early. The shoulder may be affected owing to involvement of the axillary nerve in cases of lesions of the posterior trunk, often associated with a lesion of the suprascapular nerve. Regarding the terminal branches (axillary, suprascapular and musculocutaneous nerves), spontaneous recovery may be expected in a significant proportion of cases but is often delayed (6-9 months), and the problem is to avoid unnecessary operations while not unduly delaying surgical repair in cases where it is indicated. MRI may be useful to delineate those cases where surgery is indicated: repair is usually performed around 6 months following trauma. Isolated lesions of the axillary nerve may be repaired with good results using a nerve graft. The lesion may occur in combination with a lesion of the suprascapular nerve; the latter may be interrupted at several levels. Proximal repair may be performed using a nerve graft; distal lesions are more difficult to repair and may require intramuscular neurotization. Lesions of the musculocutaneous nerve may be repaired with good results using a nerve graft. Lesions of the axillary nerve may be seen associated with lesions of the rotator cuff. The treatment varies according to the age and condition of the patient and according to the condition of the cuff muscles and tendons: in a young patient with avulsion of the tendons from bone, cuff reinsertion is indicated; in an older patient, the cuff must be evaluated by MRI or arthroscan, and repair is indicated unless the cuff tear is not amenable to surgery or there is fatty degeneration of the muscles. Palliative surgery may be indicated in cases seen late or after failed attempts at nerve repair. (ABSTRACT
本文对成人创伤性神经损伤后麻痹性肩部处理中神经修复或转移以及姑息性手术的适应证进行了批判性综述。考虑了不同情况:臂丛神经锁骨上病变后的麻痹性肩部、锁骨后和锁骨下病变后以及臂丛神经终末分支(腋神经、肩胛上神经和肌皮神经)病变后,最后是与副神经和胸长神经病变相关的问题。一、臂丛神经锁骨上病变。在完全性(C5至T1)损伤中,神经修复或转移的可能性充其量有限,目标是恢复肘部的主动屈曲。可能会联合进行姑息性手术以稳定肩部。在C5至T1神经根完全撕脱的情况下,可考虑在肱骨远端进行截肢,但如果斜方肌和前锯肌功能正常,则很少与肩关节融合术一起进行。也可使用喙肩韧带进行韧带成形术来稳定肩部。在冈上肌和肱二头肌长头已恢复但缺乏主动外旋的情况下,可通过肱骨旋转截骨术改善功能。在部分C5、6或C5、6、7损伤中,神经修复和转移的适应证更广,肌肉转移的适应证也更广。在C5、6损伤中,从副神经到肩胛上神经的神经转位可获得60%的满意结果;C5、6、7损伤治疗后也是如此,而在C5、6损伤中100%的病例可恢复肘部主动屈曲,在C5、6、7损伤中仅为86%。在肩部功能未恢复的情况下,可考虑姑息性手术:关节融合术,或更常见的是肱骨旋转截骨术,可联合大圆肌和背阔肌转移。二、臂丛神经锁骨后和锁骨下病变。25%的臂丛神经损伤发生在锁骨后或锁骨下区域,累及二级干,最常见的是后干。应尽早进行神经修复。在后部干病变的情况下,由于腋神经受累,肩部可能会受到影响,通常还伴有肩胛上神经病变。关于终末分支(腋神经、肩胛上神经和肌皮神经),在相当一部分病例中可预期自发恢复,但往往延迟(6至9个月),问题是在有手术指征的情况下避免不必要的手术,同时又不过度延迟手术修复。MRI可能有助于确定那些需要手术的病例:通常在创伤后约6个月进行修复。孤立的腋神经损伤使用神经移植修复效果良好。该损伤可能与肩胛上神经损伤同时发生;肩胛上神经可能在多个水平中断。近端修复可使用神经移植;远端损伤更难修复,可能需要肌肉内神经转位。肌皮神经损伤使用神经移植修复效果良好。腋神经损伤可能与肩袖损伤同时出现。治疗根据患者的年龄和状况以及肩袖肌肉和肌腱的状况而有所不同:在年轻患者中,如果肌腱从骨头上撕脱,应进行肩袖重新附着;在老年患者中,必须通过MRI或关节造影评估肩袖,除非肩袖撕裂无法手术或存在肌肉脂肪变性,否则应进行修复。在晚期病例或神经修复尝试失败后可能需要进行姑息性手术。(摘要)