Mateo R B, O'Hara P J, Hertzer N R, Mascha E J, Beven E G, Krajewski L P
Department of Vascular Surgery, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Ohio 44195, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 1999 May;29(5):821-31; discussion 832. doi: 10.1016/s0741-5214(99)70209-0.
The purpose of this study was to determine the safety and efficacy of the elective surgical treatment of symptomatic chronic mesenteric occlusive disease (SCMOD) and to identify the factors that influence the results of this procedure.
From 1977 to 1997, 85 patients (mean age, 62 years) underwent elective surgical treatment of SCMOD. The presenting symptoms were abdominal pain in 78 patients (92%) and weight loss in 74 patients (87%). The surgical procedures included retrograde bypass grafting in 34 patients (40%), antegrade bypass grafting in 24 patients (28%), transaortic endarterectomy in 19 patients (22%), local arterial endarterectomy with patch angioplasty in six patients (7%), thrombectomy alone in one patient (1%), and superior mesenteric artery reimplantation in one patient (1%). Thirty-five patients (41%) underwent concomitant aortic replacement. All the involved mesenteric vessels were revascularized in 21 patients (25%), whereas revascularization was incomplete for the remaining 64 patients (75%). Late information was available for all 85 patients at a mean interval of 4.8 years.
There were seven early (<35 days) postoperative deaths (8%). The cumulative 5-year survival rate was 64% (95% confidence interval [CI], 53% to 75%), and the 3-year symptom-free survival rate was 81% (95% CI, 72% to 90%). Serious complications occurred in 28 patients (33%). The results of univariate analysis identified advancing age at operation (P <.001), cardiac disease (P =.03), hypertension (P =.03), and additional occlusive disease (P =.05) as variables associated with mortality. Concomitant aortic replacement (P =.037), renal disease (P =.011), advancing age ( P =.035), and complete revascularization ( P =.032) were associated with postoperative morbidity including mortality. Late recurrent mesenteric occlusive disease was seen in 21 patients (16 symptomatic and five asymptomatic). Nine patients (43%) died, and 8 patients (38%) required subsequent surgical or endovascular procedures to treat their recurrent lesions. The 3-year survival rate from recurrent mesenteric occlusive disease was 76% (95% CI, 66% to 86%).
We conclude that the elective surgical treatment of SCMOD may be performed with reasonable early and late mortality rates and that most of the patients remain free from recurrent symptoms of mesenteric ischemia. Advancing age, cardiac disease, hypertension, and additional occlusive disease significantly influenced the overall mortality rates, and concomitant aortic replacement, renal disease, and complete revascularization were significantly associated with postoperative morbidity rates. Surveillance and appropriate correction of recurrent disease appear to be necessary for optimal long-term results.
本研究旨在确定有症状的慢性肠系膜闭塞性疾病(SCMOD)择期手术治疗的安全性和有效性,并确定影响该手术效果的因素。
1977年至1997年,85例患者(平均年龄62岁)接受了SCMOD的择期手术治疗。主要症状为腹痛78例(92%),体重减轻74例(87%)。手术方式包括逆行搭桥术34例(40%),顺行搭桥术24例(28%),经主动脉内膜切除术19例(22%),局部动脉内膜切除术加补片血管成形术6例(7%),单纯血栓切除术1例(1%),肠系膜上动脉再植术1例(1%)。35例患者(41%)同时进行了主动脉置换。21例患者(25%)所有受累肠系膜血管均实现了血运重建,其余64例患者(75%)血运重建不完全。85例患者均获得了晚期随访信息,平均随访间隔为4.8年。
术后早期(<35天)死亡7例(8%)。累积5年生存率为64%(95%可信区间[CI],53%至75%),3年无症状生存率为81%(95%CI,72%至90%)。28例患者(33%)发生严重并发症。单因素分析结果显示,手术时年龄增长(P<.001)、心脏病(P =.03)、高血压(P =.03)和其他闭塞性疾病(P =.05)是与死亡率相关的变量。同时进行主动脉置换(P =.037)、肾病(P =.011)、年龄增长(P =.035)和完全血运重建(P =.032)与包括死亡在内的术后发病率相关。21例患者(16例有症状,5例无症状)出现晚期复发性肠系膜闭塞性疾病。9例患者(43%)死亡,8例患者(38%)需要后续手术或血管内介入治疗其复发性病变。复发性肠系膜闭塞性疾病的3年生存率为76%(95%CI,66%至86%)。
我们得出结论,SCMOD的择期手术治疗可在合理的早期和晚期死亡率下进行,且大多数患者肠系膜缺血的复发症状得以缓解。年龄增长心脏病、高血压和其他闭塞性疾病显著影响总体死亡率,同时进行主动脉置换、肾病和完全血运重建与术后发病率显著相关。为获得最佳长期效果,似乎有必要对复发性疾病进行监测和适当治疗。