Postma M J, Welte R, van den Hoek J A, van Doornum G J, Coutinho R A, Jager J C
Rijksinstituut voor Volksgezondheid en Milieu (RIVM), Centrum Volksgezondheid Toekomst Verkenningen, Bilthoven.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1999 Mar 27;143(13):677-81.
To estimate the cost effectiveness of Chlamydia trachomatis (CT) screening of young women visiting general practitioners.
Economic model analysis.
Data on the health care needs for CT complications were derived from various sources; costing was done using estimated cost prices, charges and the friction cost method; epidemiological data were derived from a pilot study among 22 general practices in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. The analyses were carried out assuming screening with ligase chain reaction test of a urine sample and treatment of identified cases of infection with single-dose azitromycin. The model intervention consisted of screening all heterosexually active women aged 15-19, 15-24, 15-29, or 15-34 years (strategies 1, 2, 3 and 4, respectively). Cost effectiveness was presented in net direct and indirect costs per woman cured and per major outcome averted (pelvic inflammatory disease (PID), chronic pelvic pain, ectopic pregnancy, infertility and pneumonia of newborns).
The first two strategies were cost saving. For the third strategy net costs per woman cured and per major outcome averted were almost 110.- Dutch guilders (DFL) and over DFL 300, respectively. The last strategy costs over DFL 320 per woman cured and over DFL 910 per major outcome averted. The cost effectiveness was sensitive to the assumed probability of progression of CT infection to PID.
Universal implementation of the screening programme investigated in Amsterdam for women aged 15-24 years would result in approximately equal savings and costs. Screening of all 15-29-year-old women would require a net investment of DFL 350,000.
评估对就诊于全科医生的年轻女性进行沙眼衣原体(CT)筛查的成本效益。
经济模型分析。
CT并发症的医疗保健需求数据来自各种来源;成本核算采用估计成本价格、收费和摩擦成本法;流行病学数据来自荷兰阿姆斯特丹22家全科诊所的一项试点研究。分析假设采用尿液样本的连接酶链反应试验进行筛查,并对确诊的感染病例采用单剂量阿奇霉素治疗。模型干预包括对所有年龄在15 - 19岁、15 - 24岁、15 - 29岁或15 - 34岁的异性活跃女性进行筛查(分别为策略1、2、3和4)。成本效益以每位治愈女性和避免每种主要结局(盆腔炎(PID)、慢性盆腔疼痛、异位妊娠、不孕和新生儿肺炎)的净直接和间接成本表示。
前两种策略节省成本。对于第三种策略,每位治愈女性和避免每种主要结局的净成本分别约为110荷兰盾(DFL)和超过300荷兰盾。最后一种策略每位治愈女性的成本超过320荷兰盾,避免每种主要结局的成本超过910荷兰盾。成本效益对CT感染进展为PID的假定概率敏感。
在阿姆斯特丹对15 - 24岁女性进行调查的筛查计划的普遍实施将导致节约和成本大致相等。对所有15 - 29岁女性进行筛查将需要净投资350,000荷兰盾。